16 November 2024 in Empirical Software Engineering
Search-based software testing (SBST) is a widely-adopted technique for testing complex systems with large input spaces, such as Deep Learning-enabled (DL-enabled) systems. Many SBST techniques focus on Pareto-based optimization where multiple objectives are optimized in parallel to reveal failures. However, it is important to ensure that identified failures are spread throughout the entire failure-inducing area of a search domain, and not clustered in a sub-region. This ensures that identified failures are semantically diverse and reveal a wide range of underlying causes. In this paper, we present a theoretical argument explaining why testing based on Pareto optimization is inadequate for covering failure-inducing areas within a search domain. We support our argument with empirical results obtained by applying two widely used types of Pareto-based optimization techniques, namely NSGA-II (an evolutionary algorithm) and OMOPSO (a swarm-based algorithm), to two DL-enabled systems: an industrial Automated Valet Parking (AVP) system and a system for classifying handwritten digits. We measure the coverage of failure-revealing test inputs in the input space using a metric, that we refer to as the Coverage Inverted Distance (CID) quality indicator. Our results show that NSGA-II and OMOPSO are not more effective than a naïve random search baseline in covering test inputs that reveal failures. We show that this comparison remains valid for failure-inducing regions of various sizes of these two case studies. Further, we show that incorporating a diversity-focused fitness function as well as a repopulation operator in NSGA-II improves, on average, the coverage difference between NSGA-II and random search by 52.1%. However, even after diversification, NSGA-II still does not outperform random testing in covering test inputs that reveal failures. The replication package for this study is available in a GitHub repository (Replication package. https://github.com/ast-fortiss-tum/coverage-emse-24 2024.
20 February 2026 in Empirical Software Engineering
Scenario-based testing with driving simulators is extensively used to identify failing conditions of automated driving assistance systems (ADAS) and reduce the amount of in-field road testing. However, existing studies have shown that repeated test execution in the same as well as in distinct simulators can yield different outcomes, which can be attributed to sources of flakiness or different implementations of the physics, among other factors. In this paper, we present , a novel approach to multi-simulation ADAS testing based on a search-based testing approach that leverages an ensemble of simulators to identify failure-inducing, simulator-agnostic test scenarios. During the search, each scenario is evaluated jointly on multiple simulators. Scenarios that produce consistent results across simulators are prioritized for further exploration, while those that fail on only a subset of simulators are given less priority, as they may reflect simulator-specific issues rather than generalizable failures. Our empirical study, which involves testing three lane-keeping ADAS with increasing complexity on different pairs of three widely used simulators, demonstrates that outperforms single-simulator testing by achieving, on average, a higher rate of simulator-agnostic failures by 66%. Compared to a state-of-the-art multi-simulator approach that combines the outcome of independent test generation campaigns obtained in different simulators, identifies on average up to $$3.4\times$$ more simulator-agnostic failing tests and higher failure rates. To avoid the costly execution of test inputs on which simulators disagree, we propose an enhancement of that leverages surrogate models to predict simulator disagreements and bypass test executions. Our results show that utilizing a surrogate model during the search does not only retain the average number of valid failures but also improves its efficiency in finding the first valid failure. These findings indicate that combining an ensemble of simulators during the search is a promising approach for the automated cross-replication in ADAS testing.
5 May 2026 in Journal of Systems and Software