21 December 2016 in PeerJ
A suggested mechanism for the success of introduced non-native species is the enemy release hypothesis (ERH). Many studies have tested the predictions of the ERH using the community approach (native and non-native species studied in the same habitat) or the biogeographical approach (species studied in their native and non-native range), but results are highly variable, possibly due to large variety of study systems incorporated. We therefore focused on one specific system: plants and their herbivorous insects. We performed a systematic review and compiled a large number (68) of datasets from studies comparing herbivorous insects on native and non-native plants using the community or biogeographical approach. We performed a meta-analysis to test the predictions from the ERH for insect diversity (number of species), insect load (number of individuals) and level of herbivory for both the community and biogeographical approach. For both the community and biogeographical approach insect diversity was significantly higher on native than on non-native plants. Insect load tended to be higher on native than non-native plants at the community approach only. Herbivory was not different between native and non-native plants at the community approach, while there was too little data available for testing the biogeographical approach. Our meta-analysis generally supports the predictions from the ERH for both the community and biogeographical approach, but also shows that the outcome is importantly determined by the response measured and approach applied. So far, very few studies apply both approaches simultaneously in a reciprocal manner while this is arguably the best way for testing the ERH.
1 February 2015 in Biological Conservation
24 February 2011 in Journal of Vegetation Science
24 June 2015 in Journal of Vegetation Science
1 July 2024 in Applied Vegetation Science
Aim: There is increasing interest in open‐ended restoration with the focus on restoring natural processes rather than static compositional goals. Here, we investigated vegetation dynamics in response to three decades of trophic rewilding with large herbivores in a recent anthropogenic, fertile 55‐km2 landscape on reclaimed marine sediments. This site provides important insights into plant community assembly in rewilded, young ecosystems.Location: Oostvaardersplassen, the Netherlands.Methods: Using field surveys and vegetation data spanning two decades, we investigate vegetation dynamics of the mesic grasslands in Oostvaardersplassen, a pioneer trophic rewilding site in the Netherlands. To identify the effects of grazing and other ecological processes, we include comparisons to an adjacent ungrazed control site and to the dark diversity, that is, missing species expected to be present given the environment and geography.Results: The impact of large herbivores has led to a more open and homogenous vegetation with higher plant species richness in the mesic grasslands of Oostvaardersplassen compared to the ungrazed control. Compared to species in the dark diversity, the species present are more common in the region, more stress‐tolerant, and less competitive, in line with joint effects of grazing and immigrational lag.Conclusions: The changes in vegetation composition and structure show that rewilding with large herbivores promotes the prevalence of stress‐tolerant and low‐statured plant species, which are in decline in the broader landscape while reducing the dominance of otherwise widespread, competition‐adapted species. The absence of numerous rare species suggests that dispersal limitation poses an important constraint for the diversity build‐up in anthropogenically isolated natural areas, necessitating active species introductions to mitigate this issue in the short to medium term.
1 January 2015 in Estuarine, Coastal and Shelf Science