This article explains how the concepts of Biopolitics and homo sacer contribute to the understanding of what happened in the Villa Grimaldi concentration camp and torture center during the dictatorship of General Augusto Pinochet, in Chile. Prisoners were humiliated and tortured, losing their condition as subjects of law. The reification process of the prisoners by sadist guards and agents was added to the impossibility of the victims to legally defend themselves in front of tribunals. The archaic Roman law figure of homo sacer is perfectly applicable to explain the situation of the persons kept in clandestine concentration camps as Villa Grimaldi. The notion of superstes tormentorum (survivor of tortures) is also presented here for further discussion in order to refer to the complex and often painful process in which the ‘victims-survivors-witnesses’ of the horror of Villa Grimaldi and other similar spaces try to reinsert in society.
En este documento se analiza la experiencia de intercambio estudiantil de seis chilenos que viajaron al extranjero durante su adolescencia. Transcurridos varios años desde su retorno al país, se explica cómo los participantes evalúan la experiencia de intercambio que vivieron y las principales lecciones aprendidas. Se concluye que los programas de intercambio contribuyen a un conjunto de cambios positivos en el sujeto y que se aprecian en: una mayor valoración de la diversidad cultural, el aumento de la confianza en sí mismo, el desarrollo de pensamiento propio e independiente, mejores habilidades comunicacionales y de interacción social, y una mayor capacidad adaptativa frente a nuevas circunstancias
In the last four decades, theories and mechanisms of transitional justice have been formulated and implemented in numerous countries, forming an interdisciplinary theoretical and practical corpus. This paper proposes to expand the scope of transitional justice so that it can be applied in stable democracies. The proposed reformulation could be useful to address structural injustices affecting indigenous peoples, that are a legacy of colonialism and assimilationist policies, and to address acts of state repression that constitute serious human rights violations. These reflections are formulated on the basis of three recent case studies: 1) from the Canadian experience, the Royal Commission on Indigenous Peoples, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls are analyzed; 2) from South Africa, the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, the Constituent Process and the Land Reform are discussed; and 3) from the Chilean case, the link between social unrest and transitional justice, as well as the Constituent Process, are explained. En estas últimas cuatro décadas se han formulado teorías e implementado mecanismos de justicia transicional en numerosos países, conformando un corpus teórico-práctico interdisciplinar. En este documento se propone expandir el ámbito de acción de la justicia transicional, de modo que pueda ser aplicada en democracias estables. La reformulación que se propone podría ser de utilidad para enfrentar injusticias estructurales que afectan a los pueblos indígenas y que son un legado del colonialismo y políticas asimilacionistas, y hacerse cargo de actos de represión estatal que son constitutivos de graves violaciones a los derechos humanos. Estas reflexiones son formuladas a partir de tres recientes estudios de caso: 1) de la experiencia canadiense se analizan la Comisión Real sobre los Pueblos Indígenas, la Comisión de Verdad y Reconciliación y la Investigación Nacional sobre Mujeres y Niñas Indígenas Desaparecidas y Asesinadas; 2) de Sudáfrica, se aborda la Comisión de Verdad y Reconciliación, el Proceso Constituyente y la Reforma Agraria, y 3) del caso chileno se explica la vinculación entre estallido social y justicia transicional, además del Proceso Constituyente.
This chapter examines the political and legal complexities of the evolution in Chile from a condescending judiciary during the 17 years of military dictatorship (1973–1990) to the increasing levels of judicial independence achieved during the democratic transition that began in 1990. Citizen support was essential to the processes of reforming the judiciary and strengthening democracy and the rule of law. Since 2015, three constituent processes have taken place in Chile (2015, 2021–2022 and 2023), which have discussed, among other issues, what the organisation of the judiciary should be and how it should function. Given that this is an extremely important issue for the rule of law, the way in which judicial independence is regulated should not be improvised. It is therefore proposed to respect the standards and guiding criteria of international law on the administration of justice, paying special attention to the Inter-American human rights system on judicial independence. Reflections on the Chilean case may be useful for the path towards the rule of law in other countries in transition from authoritarian governments to increasingly democratic regimes. <!----> <!----> <!----> <!---->