Underutilized aquatic processing fractions are valuable nutritional resources, but their composition and safety profiles may vary substantially depending on species and anatomical part. This study evaluated the proximate composition, total amino acid, fatty acid, mineral, and hazardous element contents of 34 processing fractions obtained from fish, crustaceans, and tunicates to identify species- and part-specific nutritional characteristics and utilization potential. Overall, the fish-derived fractions were rich in proteins and lipids, whereas crustacean shells and tunicate tunics showed relatively high ash and carbohydrate contents. Fish skin exhibited the highest protein and total amino acid contents, with abundant glycine and proline, suggesting its potential as a collagen-rich protein source. Fish viscera contained high levels of protein, lipid, and trace minerals, while backbones and fins/tails were characterized by Ca- and P-enriched mineral profiles. Polyunsaturated fatty acids accounted for approximately 30%–50% of total fatty acids, indicating the nutritional relevance of lipid-containing fractions. Hazardous elements, including As, Cd, Pb, Hg, and MeHg, were below relevant regulatory limits in all samples. These findings demonstrate that underutilized aquatic processing fractions should not be evaluated as a single category; rather, their utilization should be guided by species group, anatomical part, and application-specific compositional characteristics.