Recent studies have shown the opportunities and limitations of participatory mapping for ecosystem services management, although it is an incipient research area. One of the research questions yet to be addressed is whether the composition of stakeholder groups has an effect on the outputs of participatory mapping. In this study, we assessed the influence of group composition on the mapped spatial distribution of ecosystem services. We developed two participatory mapping workshops of the ecosystem service supply and demand in the Nacimiento Watershed (Andalusia, Spain). In workshop 1, stakeholders were uniformly grouped according to their level of influence on land management. In workshop 2, we created mixed groups, with participants having dissimilar levels of influence on land management. The strategy of the second workshop aimed to foster social learning among participants, which was expected to influence the mapping outputs. We compared the outputs regarding the mapped spatial distribution of the ecosystem service supply and demand between the two workshops. Our results suggest that social learning occurred in groups with a mixed composition of participants, affecting the mapped spatial distribution of the supply and demand of ecosystem services. Finally, we discuss that knowledge exchange among participants can be supported through deliberative processes that occur in participatory settings, when stakeholders have different degrees of influence on land management. This can also enrich the assessment of the distribution of ecosystem services.
The installation of flower strips in simplified agricultural landscapes has been promoted as a tool to improve pollination services. While the effectiveness of flower strips in increasing pollinator visitation and yield is well-established, the social and economic feasibility of this measure remains unclear. Here, we evaluated the economic efficiency and social feasibility of installing flower strips to promote pollination under different scenarios of subsidy. A 2-year experiment was implemented by comparing sunflower fields with and without installed flower strips in central Spain, along with local farmer opinions obtained via a focus group. Flower strips significantly increased wild bee visitation to sunflower heads in the second year after implementation, with seed set being 11% higher on average in fields that had flower strips. Cost–benefit analysis revealed that investment in flower strips would be recovered by 4–5 years after installation, depending on the subsidy used. In the most favorable subsidy scenario, farmers could increase their annual benefits by 8.7% (29 €/ha) after recovering the initial investment. However, most local farmers did not perceive a significant increase in yield associated with the flower strip installation. The use of flower strips was negatively identified by farmers as a source of invasive weeds in adjacent fields, along with a lack of technical advice and economic incentives. Farmers fully agreed that direct economic subsidies were required for flower strips to be accepted as feasible approaches in the long-term.
Services écosystémiques dans le bassin méditerranéen: Le changement global, à travers l'impact des activités humaines sur les processus qui régulent le fonctionnement du système terrestre, pose des défis pour la société. L'accélération de multiples types de pressions humaines a eu des répercussions sur les systèmes socio-écologiques méditerranéens, notamment la réduction des contributions de la nature au bien-être humain, appelées services écosystémiques (SE). Un enjeu d’avenir est de comprendre comment les pressions sur les systèmes socio-écologiques (l'urbanisation, les pratiques de gestion des terres et les politiques de conservation de la nature) affectent l’approvisionnement des SE dans le bassin méditerranéen. L'objectif principal de cette thèse est d'analyser comment les flux de SE du bassin méditerranéen et les compromis entre eux sont affectés par les facteurs de changement. Une évaluation multidisciplinaire, couvrant de multiples échelles spatiales allant du bassin local au bassin méditerranéen a été utilisée pour analyser les changements dans l’offre et la demande de SE. Les impacts de l'urbanisation et des systèmes de gestion agricole couramment appliqués ce sont révélés négatifs sur l'offre de SE, ce qui pourrait entraver les progrès dans le cadre des objectifs de développement durable (ODD). Une meilleure gestion des systèmes d’utilisation des terres le long du gradient rural-urbain et l’engagement des acteurs pourraient donc contribuer à assurer les progrès des ODD. Les méthodes et les données choisies affectent les tendances des SE, les synergies et les compromis identifiés. Je conclus sur la nécessité d'appliquer une évaluation intégrée des SE pour fournir une estimation des tendances