Mário Graça Moura

Mário Graça Moura

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Mário Graça Moura

CEF.UP, School of Economics and Management, University of Porto

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

25Years (2002-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 November 2002 in Cambridge Journal of Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MMMário da Graça Moura
Mário da Graça Moura
In his recent book, Yuichi Shionoya departs from previous Schumpeterian studies. He sets out to reconstruct Schumpeter's metatheoretical framework, which he argues is the key to a correct interpretation of his substantive writings. The centrepiece of this project is the thesis that Schumpeter has a coherent methodological position—instrumentalism—which consistently underpins his theoretical work. The present paper examines this thesis, and in so doing paves the way for an alternative hypothesis on Schumpeter. This hypothesis is based on Tony Lawson's work on the philosophy of economics.

1 July 2003 in The European Journal of the History of Economic Thought
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MMMário da Graça Moura
Mário da Graça Moura
This paper assesses Joseph Schumpeter's agenda for the integration of theory and history. On the basis of a critical realist conception of the nature of historical theory it is argued that Schumpeter's aims are at odds with his analytical strategy: his implicit ontology cannot be reconciled with his conception of theory. An illustration is provided as to how this mismatch is reproduced in Schumpeter's substantive attempts to integrate theory and history, and brief reflections are offered as to why this mismatch arose and endured.

13 March 2015 in Cambridge Journal of Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MMMário Graça Moura
Mário Graça Moura
This article scrutinises the conceptions of process and order present in Schumpeter’s substantive writings. To facilitate a detailed understanding of his position, his work is examined from different angles, in three successive ‘approximations’. The coherence, or mismatch, of Schumpeter’s conceptions is subsequently discussed. The article argues that Schumpeter’s essay on social classes provides an ontologically grounded theory of process which is also a theory of reproduced order and that this theory does not fit well with Schumpeter’s alternative conception of order as equilibrium. His methodological commitment to an orthodox notion of order as equilibrium is shown to be the source of pervasive tensions in his writings, here classified as ‘retroductive problems’ and ‘spurious problems’.

21 November 2015 in Journal of Evolutionary Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
MMMário Graça Moura
Mário Graça Moura

28 July 2017 in Cambridge Journal of Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
DLDiogo Lourenco
Diogo Lourenco
MMMário Graça Moura
Mário Graça Moura
Implicitly, the Socialist Calculation Debate is about the connection between neoclassical theory and reality. It involves several ontological presuppositions, with wide-ranging implications. Our purpose is to discuss one of these presuppositions. We want to scrutinise the conception, implicit in the ‘market socialist’ arguments, that things have economic roles or functions independently of the social environment in which they exist. Primary factors and techniques of production are taken to exist independently of social arrangements; jointly with consumer preferences, they are supposed to define the economic problem of a community. In criticising this conception, we borrow from F. A. Hayek, complementing his reflections with those of Donald Davidson, Tony Lawson and others. We also discuss a second problem, which follows directly from the first: if, in contrast with the market socialists’ conception, the economic roles of things depend holistically on complex social processes, how can we compare alternative forms of economic organisation?

8 January 2024 in Cambridge Journal of Economics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
FNFrancisco Nunes-Pereira
Francisco Nunes-Pereira
MMMário Graça Moura
Mário Graça Moura
The Cambridge controversies on capital theory opposed heterodox economists, mainly from the University of Cambridge, UK, to mainstream economists, mostly based at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, USA. The controversies started in the 1950s and occupied the pages of some of the most influential journals. Their primary outcome was the broad acknowledgement of flaws, which we retrieve, in the concept of aggregate capital. Despite that acknowledgement, aggregate, homogeneous capital remains a staple of contemporary macroeconomics, as if the Cambridge controversies had never existed. To account for this apparent paradox is the aim of this article. We examine the arguments seeking to justify the enduring commitment to the aggregate capital approach and argue that they indicate an implicit commitment to instrumentalism. The indifference to the results of the Cambridge controversies is a consequence of methodological conformism and has shaky foundations.