Although the future is mentioned frequently in overarching aims and visions, and it is a major drive in the daily work of archaeological heritage managers and indeed heritage professionals more generally, it remains unclear precisely how an overall commitment to the future can best inform specific heritage practices. It seems that most archaeologists and other heritage professionals cannot easily express how they conceive of the future they work for, and how their work will impact on that future. The future tends to remain implicit in daily practice which operates in a continuing, rolling present. The authors argue that this needs to change because present-day heritage management may be much less beneficial for the future than we commonly expect.
Cultural heritage policy in the UK puts a high value on participation, and heritage agencies often encourage that participation through appealing to the endangered status of the landscapes, sites and monuments in their care. Participation takes many forms, and can involve influencing policy, contributing to cultural outputs and enjoying cultural activities. This paper critically examines the literature and discourse underpinning the endangerment/participation axis and presents a case study of heritage participation in the English Lake District. In order to ground critique in empirical investigation, the case study focusses on the practice of a particular fell shepherd, whose participation in heritage is not motivated by endangerment. The paper then explores the implications of this research for wider thinking about heritage and public life, arguing for the importance of moving beyond endangerment narratives for the creation of resilient heritage futures.
Toxic Heritage addresses the heritage value of contamination and toxic sites and provides the first in-depth examination of toxic heritage as a global issue. Bringing together case studies, visual essays, and substantive chapters written by leading scholars from around the world, the volume provides a critical framing of the globally expanding field of toxic heritage. Authors from a variety of disciplinary perspectives and methodologies examine toxic heritage as both a material phenomenon and a concept. Organized into five thematic sections, the book explores the meaning and significance of toxic heritage, politics, narratives, affected communities, and activist approaches and interventions. It identifies critical issues and highlights areas of emerging research on the intersections of environmental harm with formal and informal memory practices, while also highlighting the resilience, advocacy, and creativity of communities, scholars, and heritage professionals in responding to the current environmental crises. Toxic Heritage is useful and relevant to scholars and students working across a range of disciplines, including heritage studies, environmental science, archaeology, anthropology, and geography.
The central premise of this collection is that exploring toxic heritage as both a material phenomenon and a concept is a critical part of grappling with the damage humans have caused to the planet. In order to address this damage, we need a shared understanding of the material realities of the world, and that requires embracing environmental harm as a central heritage of modern human history (Gan et al. 2017; Garcia & Bauzà 2021; Fiske 2020; McNeill and Engelke 2014). It means naming historical conditions that brought us to this present – extractivism, carbon-based economies, environmental racism, settler-colonialism, and ongoing geo-political exploitation (Liboiron 2021; Moore 2017; Pulido 2017). It also requires paying attention to the politics of toxic heritage and the ways it traces the faultlines of social inequalities and other exercises of power. These are central issues for critical heritage studies, as other volumes in this series demonstrate, and this collection locates toxicity and environmental harm squarely in that critical heritage conversation. While heritage is historically founded with imperialism and settler colonialism (Bennett et al. 2017), critical perspectives have developed to reconfigure heritage as a tool for constructing a just future (Turunen 2020). This collection addresses a key component of any just future, namely making visible the harms of unjust, exploitative practices for people and the planet and framing them as a central part of modern human heritage.
This collection represents a cross-disciplinary conversation about the intersection of heritage as a field of discourse and practice, and toxicity as a material and social reality. It brings together authors from varied disciplinary perspectives and methodologies to explore toxic heritage as both a material phenomenon and a concept. In case studies, visual essays, and substantive chapters, scholars draw on research around the world to provide an in-depth examination of toxic heritage as a global issue. Our definition of toxic heritage has two components. First, it includes the history of the processes and substances (toxins and toxicants) that create or threaten physical harm to environments and the life supported within them (Liboiron 2017). Second, it includes the intersections of that history of harm with both formal heritage institutions and informal memory practices. This focus on the materiality of toxic substances stands in contrast to other definitions that also include social and political toxicity and other forms of “dark heritage” (Wollentz et al. 2020: 299), although the physical and metaphorical are often entangled. The attention to memory practices, processes of heritagisation, lived experiences, and the ways in which interpretations of past environmental harm are entangled with fields of power center this work within critical heritage studies.