In this paper, I describe resistance to a public housing redevelopment process in New York City. I describe the story within a theoretical approach of pragmatism, as I focus on both means and ends in planning while considering the experience and contestations of the various “publics” involved in deliberations surrounding a pilot site for mixed-income infill development. While pragmatism is helpful in reflecting on planning processes, I also simultaneously acknowledge the context of how racial capitalism has shaped and continues to impact the geography of the city, including public housing communities. As such, I propose that residents engaged in “situated resistance” as plans to radically transform the largest housing authority in the United States unfolded around them. I find that while the housing authority and residents had the same objective of preserving existing public housing, their desired paths to achieving that goal dramatically differed. I conclude by proposing that robust democratic engagement requires reparative approaches rooted in racial and economic justice that substantively and procedurally center African American communities such as those living in public housing. By introducing pragmatism alongside racial capitalism through the case of public housing redevelopment, I ultimately highlight the importance of fusing theories of democratic and structural change in urban redevelopment.
Despite being the US Department of Housing and Urban Development's largest public housing redevelopment program to date, very little research has shed light on resident experiences with the Rental Assistance Demonstration (RAD), a rapidly growing initiative that is redeveloping public housing through the introduction of nonpublic actors. In the first examination of residents’ experiences with RAD within a major US city, this article uses in-depth interviews, site visits, and descriptive statistics to contextualize how residents describe changes in their homes and communities across San Francisco, CA. I find that residents have a range of positive and negative experiences after RAD conversions. While RAD appears to be succeeding in its goals of financially stabilizing aging public housing and keeping residents in place, resident perceptions of housing quality after conversions is mixed. Further, place-based disparities embedded in public housing histories reproduce inequalities for residents living in RAD projects across the same city.