This article presents findings from a scoping review of the published literature on independent experts in care order proceedings. The aim of the review is to inform the researchers, policymakers and practitioners working at the crossroads of social work, psychology and law of the current knowledge base and gaps in the research. The review includes 43 articles from which we extracted and analysed content related to how and why independent experts are used in care order proceedings, challenges and advantages of using such experts, and the consequences of using these experts for the family. The results revealed several challenges relating to the use of independent experts and the way in which this work is organised, and their methods. The findings indicate that some challenges are caused by the various professions that are involved in these proceedings having insufficient knowledge and understanding of each other’s mandates for the work they carry out in this field. The review recommends further research on the expert reports’ impact on children and families, and how they affect the court’s decisions.
Independent experts are commonly used in child protection care proceedings to assess families and contribute to a sound basis for care order decisions. Yet the role and function of these experts varies across contexts, with issues raised concerning the quality and impact of their reports. Based on six focus group discussions (FGDs) with child welfare service (CWS) social workers in Norway, this study aims to advance the understanding of how independent experts are used when it comes to child protection. Reflexive thematic analysis was conducted, which revealed that the social workers mostly found the experts' contributions useful in that they provide a fresh pair of eyes and reduce the complexities in a case. However, the use of independent experts also had some negative aspects. The social workers experienced that their competence was undermined in court and had some experience working with experts whose work was of poor quality, which was unrecognized by quality control measures. This study raises timely questions about the role of the expert and suggests a clearer distinction between the function of providing expert knowledge to complement the social workers' assessments and the function of providing an independent assessment of the family on behalf of the courts.
17 October 2023 in The British Journal of Social Work
The processes used by social workers to collect, interpret and use stakeholder information in child protection cases are an unexplored but essential part of the decision-making process. This study focuses on social workers’ efforts to integrate the knowledge of other professionals. This article draws on a framework for managing knowledge across organisational boundaries and a process-oriented conceptualisation of knowledge integration. The analysis of ten interviews with social workers shows that the process of knowledge integration affects the basis of social workers’ decision making. We argue that knowledge possessed by other professionals is often viewed as easily transferrable and correctly received, when in fact this knowledge is often complex and subjective and requires extra effort to obtain, understand and integrate into case-specific situations. This implies a need to recognise information processing as an influencing factor in decision making within child protection that pertains to both practice and research.
19 February 2025 in The British Journal of Social Work
Although there is a growing knowledge base on children’s participation in child welfare, little research has examined the child’s position as a participant in child protection assessments undertaken by independent experts. Independent experts are commonly used in child protection care proceedings to assess families and contribute to a sound basis for care order decisions. Their reports are highly influential in the child welfare decision-making process. Based on twelve qualitative interviews with independent experts, we explore accounts of their practices of involving children in their investigation. Using a discursive approach, we analyse how the experts use various interpretative repertoires about children’s participation to reason about the position of themselves and the child as participants in the care assessment. Our analysis demonstrates four distinct positions in their discursive constructions of children’s participation. These are the protector position, the investigator position, the facilitator position, and the non-therapist position, each with a distinct interpretation repertoire. The article discusses these in relation to the specific practice context that independent expert care assessments are a part of. Further, we argue for an increased awareness of how conceptualizations of participation simultaneously contribute to what positions become available for children as participants in an independent expert care assessment.