The strategies for nucleic acid sensing based on nucleic acid hybridization between the target sequence and the capture probe sequence are considered to be largely successful as far as detection of a specific target of known sequence is concerned. However, when compared with other complementary methods, like direct sequencing, a number of results are still found to be either "false positives" or "false negatives". This suggests that modifications in these strategies are necessary to make them more accurate. In this minireview, we propose that one way toward improvement could be replacement of the DNA capture probes with the xeno nucleic acid or XNA capture probes. This is because the XNAs, especially the locked nucleic acid, the peptide nucleic acid, and the morpholino, have shown better single nucleobase mismatch discrimination capacity than the DNA capture probes, indicating their capacity for more precise detection of nucleic acid sequences, which is beneficial for detection of gene stretches having point mutations. Keeping the current trend in mind, this minireview will include the recent developments in nanoscale, fluorescent label-free applications, and present the cases where the XNA probes show clear advantages over the DNA probes.
In this work, a strategy for enhancing sensitivity in a label-free DNA detection assay, where the basic operational principle involves detection of the net surface stress induced bending motion of a piezoresistive microcantilever, upon target-binding, has been presented. A microcantilever array that allows experiments using sensor–reference configuration has been employed, where the cantilevers have been functionalized by inkjet printing technology, using short nucleic acid sequences of similar length (here, 12-mer), on both the sensor and the reference cantilevers. It is shown that application of the single stranded peptide nucleic acids (PNA), having non-ionic peptidic backbone, as the sensor probes improves the assay sensitivity about twenty times, even to the level of single base mismatch discrimination, compared to the DNA counterparts. We propose that the significantly improved performance of the PNA-based assay could be due to the orientational advantage of PNA probes as offered when a self-assembled ordered PNA structure is formed. Since the piezoresistive cantilever based method offers a practical means for target detection by rapid monitoring of the recognition events in fluid in real time, and importantly, since PNA is nuclease-resistant, this step of advancement may motivate future endeavours for detection of nucleic acid sequences in complex body fluid mimics.
So far, there has been no report on molecularly resolved discrimination of single nucleobase mismatches using surface-confined single stranded locked nucleic acid (ssLNA) probes. Herein, it is exemplified using a label-independent force-sensing approach that an optimal coverage of 12-mer ssLNA sensor probes formed onto gold(111) surface allows recognition of ssDNA targets with twice stronger force sensitivity than 12-mer ssDNA sensor probes. The force distributions are reproducible and the molecule-by-molecule force measurements are largely in agreement with ensemble on-surface melting temperature data. Importantly, the molecularly resolved detection is responsive to the presence of single nucleobase mismatches in target sequences. Since the labelling steps can be eliminated from protocol, and each force-based detection event occurs within milliseconds' time scale, the force-sensing assay is potentially capable of rapid detection. The LNA probe performance is indicative of versatility in terms of substrate choice - be it gold (for basic research and array-based applications) or silicon (for ‘lab-on-a-chip’ type devices). The nucleic acid microarray technologies could therefore be generally benefited by adopting the LNA films, in place of DNA. Since LNA is nuclease-resistant, unlike DNA, and the LNA-based assay is sensitive to single nucleobase mismatches, the possibilities for label-free in vitro rapid diagnostics based on the LNA probes may be explored.