The evidence that employees care about being treated fairly, and will react strongly to perceived unfairness, is impossible to ignore. As such, organizations are increasingly seeking ways to incorporate employee-centric principles in their decision-making processes. As a result, organizations are often challenged with balancing two sets of trade-offs: their well-being versus their employees, and their employees’ desire for equality versus equity. Ensuring these tradeoffs are consistently balanced according to the organization’s values at the scale and speed of modern business requires an algorithmic approach. The increasing use of algorithms to guide such value-driven decision-making suggests a need for better understanding of how these elements should be integrated within optimal decision-making models. Starting with a general multiobjective model, this research explores this complex trade-offs computationally by modeling two representative case studies: a synthetic gig-economy package delivery problem and an empirical interhospital patient transport problem, both of which are NP-hard. One observation we find is that certain combinations of functions in the objective of the model lead to opportunities for organizations to perform better while also representing fairness more precisely in their decision algorithms. We also find that the effects of trade-off parameters are partially determined by both their relative levels and the functions used in the objective function. These and other observations offer guidance for practice while also motivating additional research to help fully explore how these concepts shape decision-making.