This paper involves groups of children (aged 5–10) in discussing what nature is in their urban communities and how they learn about it. Children attend four urban and semi-urban Portuguese schools with different environmental pedagogies: Waldorf, forest school and eco-school. Previous studies of children’s conceptions of nature have mainly addressed environmental understanding as an individual dimension, even if acknowledging the situated nature of children’s knowledge and experience. In this study we draw on previous research, using focus groups as participatory methods that allow children to interact with their peers while expressing their visions and feelings about a topic. Group discussions show that children have a strong emotional connection with nature that generates a strongly protective disposition. Daily experiences in schools, families, and local communities but also the media reinforce this concern, and make children aware of a series of environmental problems, for which they either refer to existing rules or imagine creative solutions. On the whole, this research shows that children have a say in these matters and should therefore be involved in environmental debates and action – but also that a political ecology perspective seems to be absent from their school learning experiences.
3 September 2021 in The Journal of Environmental Education
The global COVID-19 public health crisis has driven policies of lockdowns and social distancing that have had negative social and economic impacts, worsening inequalities and social exclusions, and mixed environmental impacts. This study engaged children from schools with diverse environmental pedagogies in online focus groups about nature and their experiences with nature during the pandemic. Participants expressed fear of the unknown virus, sadness from isolation, longing for family and friends, and yearning for the freedom to enjoy the outside world. They revealed knowledge of both positive and negative impacts of lockdowns on the environment. Their experiences with nature demonstrate how environmental injustice affects the lives of children from public schools in urban contexts, especially those from lower socioeconomic backgrounds, who reported less contact with nature during the lockdown. As a group, children are aware and very critical of intergenerational environmental injustice and argue for the need for adults to act.
Esta investigação visa desocultar as visões de educadoras sobre a educação ambiental para o desenvolvimento sustentável (EADS), relacionando práticas e o papel das crianças na promoção da cidadania ambiental, por forma a caraterizar a implementação da EADS em escolas com diferentes programas e pedagogias ambientais. Foi realizado um estudo de casos múltiplos, em eco-escolas, escolas da floresta, Krishnamurti e Waldorf. As entrevistas foram realizadas a educadoras de EADS no pré-escolar e no ensino básico. Os resultados apontam diferenças não só pelas pedagogias e programas que orientam a EADS, mas também pela influência do contexto geográfico e sociocultural. A sustentabilidade ambiental é um dos aspetos mais trabalhados pelas educadoras, embora umas foquem mais as condutas pró-ambiente e outras uma preocupação com formas de vida autossustentáveis. Outro resultado importante é o amor incondicional de humanos e não humanos, como relação que permite a conexão com a natureza.
The UN’s 2030 Agenda defends Environmental Education for Sustainable Development as a way to foster environmental citizenship from childhood and highlights the role of children and young people as “critical agents of change in creating a better world” by involving them in participation in local, national, and global sustainability issues. This study explores children’s agency in environmental issues and aims to address the following research questions: What environmental problems do children see as emerging and how do they solve them? How do children perceive opportunities to participate in environmental issues? How do schools operationalize education for environmental citizenship? Focus groups were held with children aged five to eight, using elicitation images related to various environmental issues. Children reported knowledge about human impacts on the environment and expressed concerns and suggestions about environmental issues. They are also involved in a variety of pro-environmental actions in school contexts, from separating garbage, creating vegetable gardens, participating in climate strikes, and being involved in local environmental projects. Children’s agency and awareness about environmental issues appear to be closely related to the relationship they create with nature and the actual opportunities for exercising their environmental citizenship.
This commentary traces shared themes across the four chapters of Part II of this volume. The chapters share an awareness of the socially constructed nature of childhood and an interest in challenging conventional discourses about children’s competence and status. Further, all four chapters embrace the notion that classrooms are sites where children actively situate themselves socially and politically, even as each chapter examines children’s experiences along a different dimension of citizenship. Among the chapters, some tensions exist around the concept of “empowering” children and there are key differences in chosen methodologies.