Purpose: The revitalisation of tangible and intangible urban heritage can foster social cohesion and drive creativity and innovation in a changing global environment. Recognising its potential for economic development, many local municipalities are putting forward efforts to revitalise these areas. However, this has caused these sites to face new pressures, such as gentrification, demographic shifts and commercial exploitation. Therefore, a sustainable redevelopment of urban heritage sites that strikes a balance between the economic, environmental and social dimensions is needed. To plan and manage this balance, a strong and clear indicator to measure the sustainability of urban heritage is required. The study systematically reviewed through Scopus indexed journals the dimensions to develop sustainable indicators of urban heritage sites and highlighted the gaps for future research. It identified the existing studies and explored publications, research methods, challenges and suggestions to develop the indicators.Design/methodology/approach: The study applied Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) 2020 Statement. The Boolean search was in Scopus indexed journals for papers related to indicators in sustainable urban heritage sites.Findings: Most of the literature highlighted the interconnected relationships between the indicators for the sustainability of urban heritage sites: social, economic and environmental dimensions. It further revealed that for a more robust management of sustainable monitoring tools, it is crucial to include governance dimensions. Plus, technology is the intertwined aspect for the four dimensions, with culture identified as the centre for sustainability of urban heritage sites.Research limitations/implications: The paper only focused on secondary data using literature review papers that recommend gaps for future research. Possible future research includes alternative, niche literature reviews and the implementation of indicators in regional urban heritage sites.Originality/value: It created a new insight into the dimensions recommended to develop sustainable indicators for urban heritage sites.
2 June 2022 in Archnet-IJAR: International Journal of Architectural Research
Purpose: This research presents a comparative perception study towards rejuvenated, community-driven shophouses in George Town, Penang.Design/methodology/approach: It captures the opinions of two distinct age groups by utilizing a mixed-methods approach encompassing quantitative (main) and qualitative (supporting) research to obtain a dynamic understanding of perceptions between younger and older residents in the city and how these impact the long-term sustainability of heritage conservation efforts. The distribution of questionnaires to residents of Penang was the primary data collection method, with the structure of the questionnaires supported by recent academic literature and past perceptional research studies about built heritage.Findings: The four main findings from the study are therefore as follows: 1. Both age groups have a similar, positive perception towards the tangible, physical elements of rejuvenated shophouses. 2. Intangible, functional factors play an equal or stronger role in influencing people and their attitude towards public participation and overall “Sense of Place”. 3. The pessimistic “Sense of Place” responses from the “Older” group reflect an equally pessimistic attitude towards intangible, functional factors surrounding rejuvenated shophouses. 4. Youth-led changes to George Town's heritage shophouses are degrading the “sense of place” connecting the older generation to the city.Originality/value: The study can serve as a guide for the development of more inclusive and socially sustainable conservation and adaptive re-use policies for safeguarding the heritage identity and value of shophouses for current and future generations to experience in a post-COVID world.
8 September 2025 in Archnet-IJAR: International Journal of Architectural Research
Purpose: This study aims to clarify the multidimensional relationships among place attachment (PA), place identity (PI), and place dependence (PD) in heritage spatial design. Despite growing attention to emotional connections in heritage settings, the mechanisms by which spatial features shape PA—particularly through PI and PD—remain conceptually fragmented and lack an integrative spatial design perspective. Design/methodology/approach: A systematic literature review was conducted following PRISMA 2020 guidelines. Beginning with a larger sample of literature, a final total of 64 peer-reviewed articles from Scopus and Web of Science were analyzed to examine the research status, methodological approaches, and interrelations of place attachment, place identity, and place dependence in heritage contexts, with particular attention to their spatial design implications. Findings: The findings suggest that PA emerges from both symbolic and functional attachments, rooted in PI and PD, respectively. Social (intangible) and physical (tangible) spatial features contribute to these pathways through users’ perceived meanings of space. Rather than functioning independently, symbolic and functional mechanisms interact dynamically—mediated by perceived meaning—to shape attachment in heritage sites where cultural memory, emotional resonance, and spatial usability converge. Originality/value: This study introduces a dual-pathway framework that explains how spatial design features influence PA via symbolic (PI) and functional (PD) mechanisms. By integrating perceived meaning as a mediating cognitive process, the framework enhances understanding of how heritage spatial design can foster inclusive, enduring, and emotionally meaningful environments, offering both theoretical insight and practical guidance for sustainable heritage planning.
27 January 2020 in Journal of Tourism and Cultural Change
Jointly-listed with George Town as a UNESCO world heritage site since 2008, Melaka is one of the few cities in Muslim-majority Malaysia where the public display of statues is not unusual. A replica of Rio De Janeiro’s Christ the Redeemer built in the city’s Portuguese settlement in 2017 nevertheless caused controversy due to its subject matter. As the largest statue in tourist-dependent Melaka, its public acceptance is an important cultural and heritage issue. It showcases a minority community’s attempt to self-identify with a replica of a foreign cultural icon, raising questions about symbolism and authenticity surrounding how a new and imported construct can represent an old and localized culture. By highlighting the reaction of academic tourists to Melaka’s Christ the Redeemer, this study shows how a small but strongly-motivated community can create a new statue that is nevertheless accepted as a proclamation of heritage. It is an example of how even a contentious monument can be protected from demolition by adding it to society’s social conscience and ‘tourist gaze’.
Whereas the architecture of churches throughout most of Southeast Asia is typified by colonial or neocolonial typologies, the design of Catholic churches in Bali, especially since the 1970s, has been undergoing a profound localization. The brainchild of Indonesian architects, these churches combine the use of traditional and modern techniques with the labour of craftsmen who have for generations worked on the Hindu temples most tourists perceive as authentically Balinese. Using benchmarks of analysis which combine traditional Balinese belief systems with internationally-recognized measurements pertaining to architectural authenticity, this qualitative study explains the rise of ‘Bathic’ architecture as a new, authentically Balinese architectural language which even more than temple design, exists nowhere outside the shores of Bali. It shows how rarity, as a by-product of modernity, can sometimes render ‘authenticity’ on new creations to the same level as the old. It suggests a positive long-term impact for Bali's heritage tourism industry, given demographic changes and a long-term trend towards religious pluralism. It explains how, in the case of the island's ‘Bathic’ churches, outside influence has managed to create new, yet authentically Balinese buildings, which due to their touristic potential energy, are on the cusp of entering the tourist gaze.
This article is an examination of the impact of intra-Asian travel on monuments tied to colonialism in Asia. The study highlights emergent changes surrounding perceptions of tourism and what is seen as "exotic" as well as "authentic" in Asia vis-à-vis the burgeoning feeling of postcolonial guilt in the contemporary West. Citing the example of architectural monuments tied to colonial era Christian missionaries in Malaysia and Singapore, the research suggests that the 21st century is witness to a developing "postcolonial paradox" where the cultural norms and values of the prewar West are becoming more readily acceptable in parts of developing Asia than in the West itself. As "traditional values" become increasingly superseded by "progressive values" in the Western world, the premise is that the rise of the intra-Asian traveler will nevertheless allow for a belated appreciation of monuments celebrating the principles, if not the politics, of the Imperial age in Asia.