14 March 2022 in Ecology and Evolution
Syndromes, wherein multiple traits evolve convergently in response to a shared selective driver, form a central concept in ecology and evolution. Recent work has questioned the existence of some classic syndromes, such as pollination and seed dispersal syndromes. Here, we discuss some of the major issues that have afflicted research into syndromes in macroevolution and ecology. First, correlated evolution of traits and hypothesized selective drivers is often relied on as the only evidence for adaptation of those traits to those hypothesized drivers, without supporting evidence. Second, the selective driver is often inferred from a combination of traits without explicit testing. Third, researchers often measure traits that are easy for humans to observe rather than measuring traits that are suited to testing the hypothesis of adaptation. Finally, species are often chosen for study because of their striking phenotypes, which leads to the illusion of syndromes and divergence. We argue that these issues can be avoided by combining studies of trait variation across entire clades or communities with explicit tests of adaptive hypotheses and that taking this approach will lead to a better understanding of syndrome‐like evolution and its drivers.
1 January 2021 in Molecular Phylogenetics and Evolution
12 April 2025 in Annals of Botany
Background: Leaf economics theory holds that physiological constraints to photosynthesis have a role in the coordinated evolution of multiple leaf traits, an idea that can be extended to carnivorous plants occupying a particular trait space that is constrained by key costs and benefits. Pitcher traps are modified leaves that may face steep photosynthetic costs: a high-volume, three-dimensional tubular structure may be less efficient than a flat lamina. While past research has investigated the photosynthetic costs of pitchers, the exact suite of constraints shaping pitcher trait variation remain under-explored, including constraints to carnivorous function. Scope: In this review, we describe various constraints arising from the dual photosynthetic and carnivorous functions of pitchers arising from developmental, functional, budgetary and environmental factors. In addition, we identify the data required to establish the leaf economics spectrum (LES) for carnivorous pitcher plants (CPPs), and – owing to the multifunctional roles of pitcher leaves – discuss difficulties in placing pitchers onto existing frameworks. Conclusion: Because pitcher traps serve multiple functions, both photosynthesis and nutrient acquisition (carnivory), they are difficult to place in the context of the LES, especially in light of a current lack of trait data. We describe a spectrum across the independent CPP lineages in approaches to balancing carnivory–photosynthesis tradeoffs. Future efforts to collect relevant data can clarify the forces that shape observed pitcher trait variation, and increase understanding of principles that may be ultimately generalized to other plants.
8 October 2023 in American Journal of Botany
24 May 2025 in Evolution & Development
Prey attraction is an integral component of the carnivorous syndrome, yet its molecular adaptations have remained largely unexplored. Our study utilized tissue‐specific transcriptomic data from the South American marsh pitcher plant, Heliamphora tatei , to explore the molecular and developmental basis of prey attraction. Carnivorous plants often present specialized structures associated with prey attraction and in Heliamphora , that function is carried out by the nectar spoon, a colorful extension of the top of the pitcher that is densely covered in nectaries. Through comparisons of gene expression in the nectar spoon with the rest of the pitcher, we identified a suite of differentially expressed genes that likely contribute to prey attraction, including enzymes involved in volatile synthesis and sugar transporters. We found that one lineage of sugar transporters, the 14a clade of SWEET s (Sugars Will Eventually Be Exported Transporters), is highly upregulated in the nectar spoon and has evolved more rapidly in Sarraceniaceae, consistent with specialization for nectar transport as part of prey attraction. Among the genes related to volatile production, we found several enzymes best known for their role in floral scent. These results suggest that, similar to prey digestion, ancient genes are repurposed for novel functions during the transition to carnivory and may facilitate the repeated convergent origins of carnivory across angiosperms.
19 December 2025 in bioRxiv
Carnivorous plants (CPs) are striking examples of convergent evolution across ecological, morphological, and molecular scales, making them ideal systems for investigating genomic adaptation to extreme environments. While genomic studies have shown that gene family expansion and functional recruitment underlie key carnivorous traits, the effects of these transitions on rates of sequence evolution remain incompletely understood. Here, we present a comparative framework to examine evolutionary rate shifts across 30 carnivorous and non-carnivorous eudicots in over 12,000 gene families. Analyzing branch-lengths and evolutionary rate covariation (ERC), we detect both lineage-specific and convergent acceleration in CPs for genes associated with stress response, stimulus signaling, and light perception. Accelerated genes often belong to expanded families and show relaxation of purifying selection pressure. Despite the limited number of specific genes or gene families showing convergent acceleration across CP lineages, we find strong convergence at the functional level. Distinct sets of accelerated genes in each CP lineage are enriched for similar functional pathways, particularly light and hormone responses. ERC network analysis identifies a stress- and stimulus-responsive gene community with lineage-specific acceleration in Sarraceniaceae species and moderate acceleration in other CP lineages. Hub genes in this network are also co-expressed in a distantly related non-CP model system, suggesting repeated co-option of an ancestral regulatory module for carnivorous functions. Together, our results show that convergent genomic rate accelerations in CPs primarily involve functionally equivalent or similar but lineage-distinct genes, shaped by gene duplication, relaxed selection, and co-option of stress-response networks.