10 October 2020 in Entrepreneurship Theory and Practice
In many markets, there are mediators whose public evaluations mark that a new entrepreneur has gained legitimacy. Their decision may be influenced by third-party sources signaling about the entrepreneur. We quantitatively study these micro-level processes in the art market, where the artist is the entrepreneur and the art gallery is the mediator. Our results show that it is not the quantity but the diversity of signaling sources, especially highly credible ones, that influence a mediator’s decision. This allows entrepreneurs full access to the market under the consensus that “proper” legitimacy has been gained. Our conclusions are maintained under alternative analyses.
1 September 2020 in International Journal of Research in Marketing
29 January 2026 in Organization Studies
Originality is widely regarded as a determinant of an artist’s canonization, yet its long-term impact on cultural valuation remains underexplored. In this study, we address this gap by using advanced deep learning methods to gain new theoretical insights into the relationship between artists’ visual originality and their art historical significance. We conceptualize visual originality as the extent to which novelty—expressed solely in the visual features of artworks—affects the overall value of a focal artist, as determined by expert, peer, and market-based evaluative regimes. To empirically examine this relationship, we analyze 60,011 paintings spanning six centuries of fine art using computer vision methods. We also construct a comprehensive dataset and utilize text analysis to quantify the canonical importance of the 942 artists who created these paintings. Additionally, we develop a peer influence metric that gauges the importance of artistic novelty on subsequent artists. Our findings show that visual originality is a significant determinant of artists’ long-term standing in the art canon across all evaluative regimes. Moreover, there is a strong, positive relationship between artists’ visual originality within a stylistic movement and artists’ canonical rankings, particularly for expert and market regimes. Finally, we show that early innovators within a stylistic movement are significantly more likely to attain enduring art historical esteem, underscoring the importance of visual originality at the forefront of emerging artistic trends. Our findings are robust and validated across different contexts and time periods, while our methods extend the use of computational image and text analysis in organization studies research.