Annual pasture legume species can vary more than 3-fold in their critical external phosphorus (P) requirement (i.e. P required for 90% of maximum yield). In this work we investigated the link between root morphology, P acquisition and critical external P requirement among pasture species. The root morphology acclimation of five annual pasture legumes and one grass species to low soil P availability was assessed in a controlled-environment study. The critical external P requirement of the species was low (Dactylis glomerata L., Ornithopus compressus L., Ornithopus sativus Brot.), intermediate (Biserrula pelecinus L., Trifolium hirtum All.) or high (Trifolium subterraneum L.). Root hair cylinder volumes (a function of root length, root hair length and average root diameter) were estimated in order to assess soil exploration and its impact on P uptake. Most species increased soil exploration in response to rates of P supply near or below their critical external P requirement. The legumes differed in how they achieved their maximum root hair cylinder volume. The main variables were high root length density, long root hairs and/or high specific root length. However, total P uptake per unit surface area of the root hair cylinder was similar for all species at rates of P supply below critical P. Species that maximised soil exploration by root morphology acclimation were able to prolong access to P in moderately P-deficient soil. However, among the species studied, it was those with an intrinsic capacity for a high root-hair-cylinder surface area (i.e. long roots and long root hairs) that achieved the lowest critical P requirement.
Context: Improving the stability of legumes in grasslands in the face of variable seasonal conditions is key to mitigating risks posed by drought. Aims: We assessed the persistence of a range of legume species and cultivars in order to inform legume choice for pasture improvement and identify priority species for further development. Methods: Twenty field experiments in four series were conducted at sites with contrasting seasonal and soil characteristics in the ‘high-rainfall’ (560–920 mm long-term average) Tablelands and Monaro regions of New South Wales, Australia. Legumes were grown as pure swards and assessed periodically for seedling density, plant frequency and dry matter for up to 5 years. Key results: Legume dry matter production was positively correlated with plant frequency. However, most legumes persisted poorly at most sites, particularly on soils of lower fertility. Subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum) cv. Goulburn was the best performing cultivar of that species across sites on the Southern Tablelands and Monaro. Yellow serradella (Ornithopus compressus) cvv. Avila and Yellotas showed promising persistence, particularly under drought conditions. White clover (T. repens) was the most broadly adapted of the perennial legumes across a range of soils, but persistence was still inadequate at many sites. Lucerne (Medicago sativa) was approximately twice as productive as the next-most productive species when soil conditions suited its growth, but it failed to persist on acidic, low-fertility soils. Conclusions: Serradella species (yellow and French, O. sativus) and white clover, in conjunction with subterranean clover, offer the best near-term prospects for diversifying legume productivity and resilience under variable seasonal conditions in tableland environments. Implications: An increased focus on phenology and seed characteristics is suggested to improve the persistence of annual and facultative perennial legume species in grasslands. Serradella and white clover are identified as the highest priorities for cultivar development for tableland environments of south-eastern Australia.
Context: Serradellas (Ornithopus spp.) are promising alternative annual legumes to subterranean clover (Trifolium subterraneum L.), for permanent, temperate pastures. However, many cultivars exhibit unstable flowering dates across years. This is a risk for seed production and persistence. Aim: This study assessed how vernalisation and photoperiod cues determine maturity type and flowering date stability among serradella cultivars. Methods: First flower appearance was recorded for early and late maturing cultivars of yellow serradella (Ornithopus compressus L.), French serradella (Ornithopus sativus Brot.) and subterranean clover after exposure to six vernalisation treatments (0, 1, 3, 5, 7 or 9 weeks at 5°C) with subsequent growth under four photoperiods (8, 12, 16 or 20 h). Key results: ‘Intrinsic earliness’ differed by only zero to three nodes for cultivars within species, indicating that maturity type was determined primarily by a cultivar’s responses to vernalisation and photoperiod. An interaction between these responses was observed, with a precipitous decline in the requirement for vernalisation when photoperiods exceeded 12 h. Many cultivars also displayed a persistent component to their vernalisation response, whereby long photoperiods (20 h) did not completely negate the response to vernalisation. Conclusions: Later maturity was associated particularly with need for long exposure to the vernalisation treatment to minimise the duration from sowing to first flower appearance. Stable flowering is more likely when a cultivar has components of its vernalisation requirement that are not satisfied before autumn ends to prevent premature flowering, and a photoperiod response in spring that overrides any unmet vernalisation requirement. Implications: Persistence by serradella cultivars requires selection for suitable responsiveness to vernalisation and photoperiod.