Sorbent-based atmospheric water harvesting promises passive, geography-independent, and economical freshwater production. Achieving low water cost through moisture harvesting demands inexpensive, high-performance, and durable sorbents. Among all sorbents, hydrogel salt-composites have exceptional performance at a low cost. However, hydrogel durability has so far been overlooked, ultimately preventing moisture capture from realizing reliable, inexpensive water production. In this work, we systematically study hydrogel-salt composite degradation under different conditions. We demonstrate that commonly used polyacrylamide-lithium chloride (PAM-LiCl) are intrinsically durable, with a limited decrease (~50%) in their elastic moduli, even at elevated temperatures (75 °C) and for prolonged durations (>8 months). In contrast, degradation quickly occurs (<3 weeks) when these hydrogels interface with copper and copper oxides, as is common practice in moisture-harvesting devices or for polyvinyl alcohol-lithium chloride hydrogels (in 190 cycles) and provides a path towards <0.01 $/L water from moisture.