1 September 2021 in Spirituality in Clinical Practice
29 August 2023 in Journal of Anomalous Experience and Cognition
Objective: We used the ChatGPT-3.5 artificial intelligence (AI)-based language program to compare twelve types of mystical, supernatural, or otherwise anomalous entity encounter narratives constructed from material in the publicly available corpus of information, and compared their details to the phenomenology of spontaneous accounts via the Survey of Strange Events (SSE) and the grounded theory of Haunted People Syndrome (HP-S). Methods: Structured content analysis by two independent and masked raters explored whether the composite AI-narratives would: (a) cover each encounter type, (b) map to the SSE’s Rasch hierarchy of anomalous perceptions, (c) show an average SSE score, and (d) reference the five recognition patterns of HP-S. Results: We found moderate evidence of a core encounter phenomenon underlying the AI-narratives. Every encounter type was represented by an AI-generated description that readily mapped to the SSE, albeit their contents showed only fair believability and low but generally positive correlations with each other. The narratives also corresponded to below-average SSE scores and referenced at least one HP-S recognition pattern. Conclusions: Prototypical depictions of entity encounter experiences based on popular source material certainly approximate, yet not fully match, the phenomenology of their real-life counterparts. We discuss the implications of these outcomes for future studies.
30 June 2023 in Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik
The grounded theory of Haunted People Syndrome (HP-S) contends that spontaneous ‘ghostly episodes’ recurrently experienced by certain people are an interactionist phenomenon involving heightened somatic-sensory sensitivities which are stirred by dis-ease states, contextualized with paranormal belief, and reinforced via perceptual contagion and threat-agency detection. A historical report of a poltergeist-like outbreak that was touted in a non-psi journal was used to test the applicability of this psychological model. Two independent and blinded raters used the Survey of Strange Events (SSE: Houran et al., 2019b) to map the anomalous phenomena in the case, as well as a Recognition Pattern Checklist to assess for contextual variables that the HP-S model links to the features and dynamics of sustained haunt-type anomalies. High inter-rater agreement on the raters’ scores suggested that the available details of this case corresponded to (a) an occurrence with above-average ‘haunt intensity’ compared to published norms, and (b) 100% ‘agreement’ on the ostensible presence of all five proposed recognition patterns of HP-S. Furthermore, a review of this episode’s general structure using an SSE based Decision-Tree process cautioned against a purely parapsychological interpretation of some or all the reported anomalies. This basic analysis serves as a practical primer for using the SSE tool and HP-S model to guide future investigations of ghostly episodes by professional parapsychologists and citizen scientists alike.
31 March 2025 in Journal of Scientific Exploration
Auerbach et al. (2023) proposed an AECKO model to describe the features and dynamics of a poltergeist-like disturbance they investigated with virtual technology during the COVID-19 pandemic. A two-part exercise nonetheless shows that their findings fundamentally support Laythe, Houran, Dagnall et al.’s (2021) grounded theory of Haunted People Syndrome (HP-S), which was independently developed at an earlier time. HP-S asserts that ghostly episodes recurrently manifesting to certain people are an interactionist phenomenon emerging from individuals with heightened somatic-sensory sensitivities, which are stirred by dis-ease states, contextualized with paranormal belief, and reinforced via perceptual contagion and threat-agency detection. Part 1 of our research identified strong conceptual parallels between the AECKO and HP-S models, whereas Part 2 involved a content analysis by an independent and clinically-trained researcher (with cross-checking by an expert panel) who used standardized measures to compare Auerbach et al.’s case to the phenomenology of ‘spontaneous’ ghostly episodes and the five recognition patterns of HP-S. The available data suggested this case had below-average ‘haunt intensity’ that closely approximated baseline scores for Illicit and Fantasy narratives. Likewise, its S/O distribution pattern most resembled accounts with knowingly embellished or false testimony. These results imply that the anomalies considered here were not expressly ‘spontaneous.’ Content analysis further detected a majority of the HP-S recognition patterns in the case material, as well as evidence that the apparent focus person strongly matched the psychometric profile of poltergeist agents found in prior research. Auerbach et al.’s data, therefore, arguably provide good concurrent validity for the HP-S model. Taken altogether, we assert that ghostly episodes are best conceptualized, researched, and addressed through a biopsychosocial lens and phenomenological approach, irrespective of the potential contribution of putative psi. We discuss these ideas relative to new research directions and clinical applications.
9 July 2024 in Journal of Scientific Exploration
20 December 2024 in Journal of Anomalistics / Zeitschrift für Anomalistik
This pre-registered study tested the concept of an ‘enchantment–psi loop’ via distinct immersive visits to sacred, haunted, and augmented reality environments. In particular, we specified four hypotheses based on the premise that anomalous experiences and cognitions would significantly shift by applying a Paranormal Belief × Transliminality × Enchantment formula. A vetted sample of thin-boundary participants (n = 22) organized into small tour groups completed measures of environmental features, real-time encounter experiences, enchantment levels, and a computerized test of putative psi after counterbalanced exposure to each of the three ‘enchanted’ conditions, as well as paired testing sessions within a purposely ‘disenchanted’ environment. Our hypotheses received mixed support. Consistent with predictions, participants’ scores on both encounter experiences and psi performance increased in the enchanted vs. disenchanted conditions, though situational-enchantment levels correlated positively with encounter experiences and negatively with putative psi. Participants also tended to have above-chance scores in the enchanted conditions, but many of our predicted effects did not reach statistical significance. Tangential analyses revealed that both encounter experiences and putative psi were also influenced differentially by various emotional (i. e., feelings of happiness), motivational (i. e., attentional focus), and environmental (i. e., sentimentality and presence) factors. The results lend credence to aspects of the enchantment-psi loop yet indicate the need for future research to clarify important nuances or complexities with the model that likely affect the reliability or robustness of its predictions.