Proper tuning of catalyst properties is a fundamental strategy for controlling the reaction rate, coking rate, product selectivity (H2/CO), and sintering resistance in dry reforming of methane (DRM). In this study, we demonstrate that the exsolution of Ni from NiCr2O4 synthesized at different temperatures (500-800°C) provides a pathway for efficient DRM. Higher synthesis temperatures alter the spinel proportion and crystal size in the NiCr2O4/NiO/Cr2O3 mixed phase. The synthesis temperature induced well-defined trends in the dynamics of Ni surface concentration during reduction, exsolution kinetics, reducibility, and active-site density. Consequently, we achieved precise control of reaction rate, coking resistance, product selectivity (H2/CO), and catalyst sintering resistance during DRM. In situ near-ambient-pressure X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) revealed that exsolution lingers beyond the reduction regime, thereby facilitating changes in Ni surface concentration during the reaction regime. Additionally, we achieved a case that is atypical in DRM: rCH4' > rCO2', with a relatively low normalized coking rate. Cr2O3 support under reaction conditions remained stable, yielding high H2 selectivity (H2/CO =~ 0.8) compared to ~0.6 for Ni/MgAl2O4. Atomistic simulations conducted to elucidate the catalytic behavior reveal that Ni diffusion in NiCr2O4 has a low migration barrier of 0.38 eV, indicating that Ni transport is kinetically accessible. This high mobility promotes the exsolution of Ni nanoparticles, which act as active catalytic sites. The study provides valuable insights into the use of spinels to control catalyst performance in DRM, paving the way for the design of efficient DRM catalysts.