3 November 2016 in Physical Therapy Reviews
Objectives: To identify the definitions used for treatment fidelity in the behaviour change literature and to explore the extent to which the assessment of fidelity has been reported according to the five domains by Bellg et al. Methods: Three databases (Scopus, Medline Ovid and CINAHL) were searched. Results were limited to studies published between 2012 and 2015. Definitions/summaries of treatment fidelity used were recorded. Methods for assessing/monitoring treatment fidelity were extracted, summarised and categorised according to the five domains. Results: Sixty-five papers were included for analysis. A definition of treatment fidelity was provided by n = 34 studies; n = 9 defined fidelity according to Bellg et al. In the context of treatment fidelity, n = 9 (13.8%) reported on study design; n = 22 (33.8%) reported on an element of training of providers; n = 59 (90.7%) papers reported on delivery of treatment; n = 13 (20%) reported on receipt of treatment; and n = 10 (15.3%) reported on enactment of treatment skills. Conclusion: The definitions of treatment fidelity in the literature and the extent to which it has been reported were limited. Delivery of treatment was the most frequently reported component of treatment fidelity but other important aspects were poorly reported. The potential consequence of this is that translation of research interventions into clinical practice may not be optimised.
4 May 2018 in COPD: Journal of Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Pulmonary rehabilitation (PR) may not suit all individuals with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) and may not result in increased physical activity. Higher levels of physical activity are associated with reduced mortality and morbidity. The aim of this study was to assess the feasibility of conducting a trial to investigate the effectiveness of a clinician-facilitated physical activity intervention (PAI) versus PR in improving physical activity in patients with COPD referred to PR. In this randomised controlled mixed methods feasibility study, all patients referred to PR who were eligible and willing were assessed at baseline and then randomised to the PAI or to PR. The assessments were repeated post-intervention and at 3-month follow-up. The main outcome was step count measured by Actigraph. Semi-structured interviews were conducted post-intervention. The N = 50 patients; mean (SD) age, 64.1(8.6) years, 24M were recruited and randomised; N = 23 (PAI) and n = 26 (PR): one patient was excluded from the analysis as that person did not meet the GOLD diagnostic criteria. Key feasibility criteria were met; recruitment was 11%, dropouts in PAI were 26% (n = 6) and 50% (n = 13/26) PR. Participants in both groups experienced a range of health benefits from their respective programmes. The PAI appears to be effective in increasing step counts in people with COPD: mean change (standard deviation) [confidence interval] for the PAI group was 972.0(3230.3)[-1080.3 to 3024.4], n = 12 and 4.3(662.7)[-440.9 to 449.5], n = 11 for the PR group. The PAI met all domains of fidelity. This study provides key information to inform a future-randomised controlled trial in physical activity.
28 November 2022 in BMC Pulmonary Medicine
KOKatherine M. A. O’rEilly
Background: Pulmonary rehabilitation (PR) is recommended in the treatment of people with idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF). Little is known about the experiences of people with IPF of PR. Due to Covid-19 there has been a rapid shift of PR services to remote/virtual delivery. Objective: To explore people living with IPFs experience of a virtual PR (VPR) programme. Methods: All patients with a diagnosis of IPF in a stable phase of the disease were invited to participate in virtual PR: a 10 week exercise programme delivered twice-weekly for one hour. One-to-one semi- structured interviews were conducted within one week following the programme. All interviews were recorded, transcribed and analysed using Braun and Clarke thematic analysis by two independent assessors. Results: N=13 participants took part in the semi-structured interviews, mean (standard deviation (SD)) age 69.5(10.4) years; 7M:6F. Mean (SD) FEV1 2.6(0.3)L, FVC 2.9(0.4)L. Four key themes were identified: 1) The impact of VPR on health and outlook, (2) The reality of VPR, (3) Being active after VPR and (4) Living with IPF during the COVID-19 Pandemic. Participants reported high levels of enjoyment and engagement with the programme regardless of the health benefits experienced. Most participants expressed a desire for a longer programme. Participants expressed different levels of maintenance with exercise since finishing the programme, specific motivators and strategies for maintenance included lung transplant, the maintenance of benefits from the programme and social support. COVID-19 and the restrictions imposed had some negative impacts on some participants lives, engaging with PR helped overcome some of these. Conclusion: Despite the progressive nature of IPF, all participants expressed high levels of enjoyment with the programme. Future research should explore strategies for maintenance post PR and the optimum duration of PR for people with IPF.
14 April 2021 in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
20 February 2023 in International Journal of Healthcare Simulation
Background Globally, practice education is a core component of physiotherapy training. Physiotherapy educators struggle to find sufficient workplace placements to ensure adequate clinical experience. Simulation-based learning (SBL) could complement clinical workplace experiences and bridge the gap between demand and provision. This study explores academic physiotherapy educators’ views and experiences of practice education and the potential contribution of SBL. Methods Representatives from all six Schools of Physiotherapy on the island of Ireland participated in focus groups. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. Qualitative data were analysed using interpretive description methodology. Results We conducted seven focus groups with 29 academic educators (26 females and 3 males). Three core themes were identified: (i) challenges in practice education, (ii) the potential for SBL in practice education and (iii) barriers and enablers to integrating SBL in practice education. COVID-19 had dual impacts, both exacerbating challenges and precipitating innovations in practice education. Analysis revealed guidance for how to fit SBL within practice education although varied understanding and limited experience with using SBL remained. Barriers to SBL included cost, time, logistics and stakeholder buy-in, while collaboration represented a key facilitator. Perceived benefits of SBL included enhanced student capacity and experience. Conclusions A number of contributing factors threaten traditional workplace-based physiotherapy practice education in Ireland. SBL may reduce this threat and solicit ever better performances from students. Future research should examine the feasibility of proposed SBL deployment and foster buy-in from key stakeholders. Background Globally, practice education is a core component of physiotherapy training. Physiotherapy educators struggle to find sufficient workplace placements to ensure adequate clinical experience. Simulation-based learning (SBL) could complement clinical workplace experiences and bridge the gap between demand and provision. This study explores academic physiotherapy educators’ views and experiences of practice education and the potential contribution of SBL. Methods Representatives from all six Schools of Physiotherapy on the island of Ireland participated in focus groups. Interviews were audio-recorded and transcribed. Qualitative data were analysed using interpretive description methodology. Results We conducted seven focus groups with 29 academic educators (26 females and 3 males). Three core themes were identified: (i) challenges in practice education, (ii) the potential for SBL in practice education and (iii) barriers and enablers to integrating SBL in practice education. COVID-19 had dual impacts, both exacerbating challenges and precipitating innovations in practice education. Analysis revealed guidance for how to fit SBL within practice education although varied understanding and limited experience with using SBL remained. Barriers to SBL included cost, time, logistics and stakeholder buy-in, while collaboration represented a key facilitator. Perceived benefits of SBL included enhanced student capacity and experience. Conclusions A number of contributing factors threaten traditional workplace-based physiotherapy practice education in Ireland. SBL may reduce this threat and solicit ever better performances from students. Future research should examine the feasibility of proposed SBL deployment and foster buy-in from key stakeholders.