Online physical education (OLPE) expanded rapidly during the COVID-19 pandemic and has continued to serve as a supplementary or alternative approach to delivering physical education (PE) in K–12 education. However, questions remain regarding its effectiveness, instructional quality, and capacity to achieve traditional PE learning objectives. This review examined the current status of OLPE in the United States, focusing on four dimensions: program effectiveness, PE teacher preparedness, student perspectives, and state policies governing online PE. A literature search was conducted using Scopus and Google Scholar to identify relevant publications from January 2010 through 2026. Search terms included online physical education, virtual physical education, teacher preparedness, student perspectives, physical activity, motor-skill development, instructional quality, and state policy. Relevant state statutes, national reports, and educational policy documents were also examined. International and higher education studies were considered when they provided contextual insights, with findings distinguished from evidence directly applicable to U.S. K–12 settings. At least 31 states explicitly authorize secondary school students to earn required physical education (PE) graduation credits through online coursework. The findings indicate that OLPE effectiveness varies according to instructional design, student engagement, opportunities for physical activity, and the outcomes assessed. Enrollment and lesson completion do not necessarily translate into meaningful physical activity or motor-skill development. Teachers face challenges related to technological competence, online pedagogical preparation, and institutional support. Students’ experiences are influenced by motivation, teacher–student interaction, technology access, and the availability of adequate space and equipment. Furthermore, state policies vary considerably, creating differences in authorization and implementation. This review highlights the need for specialized teacher professional development, consistent quality standards, and comprehensive program evaluation. Future research should integrate teacher preparedness, student experiences, instructional quality, and objective measures of physical activity and learning to identify the conditions under which OLPE can effectively support K–12 physical education.