Objective: To compare early and 1-y outcomes after anterior-to-posterior screw fixation and direct posterior fixation of the posterior malleolus in Weber type C trimalleolar ankle fractures. Methods: This retrospective cohort study included 183 patients: 78 treated with anterior-to-posterior fixation and 105 with direct posterior fixation. The visual analog scale (VAS), Olerud-Molander Ankle Score (OMAS), and American Orthopaedic Foot and Ankle Society (AOFAS) ankle-hindfoot score were assessed at 3 mo and 1 y. Radiological alignment, residual posterior step-off, ankle motion, and return to work were also compared. Results: At 3 mo, posterior fixation was associated with lower VAS scores (mean [SD], 0.99 [1.07] vs 2.09 [1.14]), higher OMAS (mean [SD], 82.11 [6.68] vs 72.76 [8.78]), and higher AOFAS scores (mean [SD], 85.19 [6.82] vs 76.78 [7.87]; all P < .001). These scores did not differ significantly at 1 y. Syndesmotic screw fixation was less frequent after posterior fixation (4.8% vs 94.9%; P < .001). Residual posterior step-off was slightly lower after posterior fixation (mean [SD], 0.06 [0.14] mm vs 0.09 [0.13] mm; P = .01), with all values below 2 mm. Mortise alignment, final ankle motion, and return-to-work time were comparable between groups. Conclusions: Direct posterior fixation was associated with better early pain and function and less frequent syndesmotic screw fixation. Clinical outcomes converged and were similar at 1 y. Prospective studies are needed to determine whether these associations are causal.