In each step of the creative writing process, writers must grapple with their creative goals and individual perspectives. This process affects the writer’s sense of authenticity and their engagement with the written output. Fluent text generation by AIs risks undermining the reflective loop of rewriting. We hypothesize that deliberately generating imperfect intermediate text can encourage rewriting and prompt higher level decision making. Using logs from 27 writing sessions using a text generation AI, we characterize how writers adapt and rewrite AI suggestions, and show that intermediate suggestions significantly motivate and increase rewriting. We discuss the implications of this finding, and future steps for investigating how to leverage intermediate text in AI writing support tools to support ownership over creative expression.
Documentation can support design work and create opportunities for learning and reflection. We explore how a novel documentation tool for a remote interaction design course provides insight into design process and integrates strategies from expert practice to support studio-style collaboration and reflection. Using Research through Design, we develop and deploy Kaleidoscope, an online tool for documenting design process, in an upper-level HCI class during the COVID-19 pandemic, iteratively developing it in response to student feedback and needs. We discuss key themes from the real-world deployment of Kaleidoscope, including: tensions between documentation and creation; effects of centralizing discussion; privacy and visibility in shared spaces; balancing evidence of achievement with feelings of overwhelm; and the effects of initial perceptions and incentives on tool usage. These successes and challenges provide insights to guide future tools for design documentation and HCI education that scaffold learning process as an equal partner to execution.
Existing literature on designing AI technologies focuses on personifying the AI system using metaphors like "collaborator" or "teammate." However, these personifying metaphors may have problematic consequences and do not reflect the full breadth of the design space for human-AI interaction. We report the design process of, and initial results from, a participatory speculative design workshop that supports participants in designing AI systems using novel, non-human metaphors. We articulate two current design recommendations for interaction or workshop designers interested in AI and metaphors: Defamiliarization of AI may support creative interpretation of ambiguous metaphors and Explicit metaphorical thinking may scaffold participants’ use of ambiguity as a resource. We also discuss two potential results suggested by our initial data collection: Ambiguous metaphorical thinking may support groups negotiating values and The term AI may limit attempts at defamiliarization.
Writing assistants are becoming increasingly sophisticated and ubiquitous, fueled by advances in artificial intelligence, particularly large language models. As new use cases and models emerge, we expect the adoption rate to accelerate. This brings a sense of urgency to understanding not just the benefits, but also the potential dark sides of intelligent writing assistants. In this interdisciplinary workshop, we will explore the challenges and dark sides that our communities may have to consider as we design and deploy new tools and technologies, as well as how to prevent them. We will build off the successful workshop at CHI23 (The Second In2Writing Workshop), bringing new voices to the vibrant community of writing tools researchers established there, and building on the design space created by prior workshop participants. We invite writers, educators, researchers, industry practitioners, students, and anyone interested in creating, using, and testing future writing assistant technologies to join the conversation.