Research on Chinese students’ well-being remains limited. Using the 2020 wave of the China Family Panel Studies, a large, nationwide dataset involving 6,568 participants across 4,782 households, we examine how social capital, higher education, and Internet use collectively shape college students’ subjective well-being in urban and rural settings, test a new education-happiness paradox, and offer the following novel discoveries. Urban students with both high social capital and higher education report the highest well-being. Rural students with high social capital but lower education rank second. With low educational levels, increases in social capital lead to greater well-being gains for rural students than urban students. Interestingly, with high social capital, higher education predicts the highest well-being for urban students but the lowest for rural students. Internet use not only facilitates connections but also detracts from face-to-face interactions and partially mediates the relationship between social capital and students’ well-being. As educational achievement increases, the added benefit of social capital for well-being decreases. Our new education-happiness paradox provides essential insights and helps policymakers and educators balance educational growth, foster social capital, promote responsible Internet use, and achieve equitable, sustainable, and subjective well-being across diverse student groups.