Lisa Bender

Lisa Bender

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Lisa Bender

University of Freiburg Freiburg Germany

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

6Years (2021-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
23 March 2021 in Applied Cognitive Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LBLisa Bender
Lisa Bender
ARAlexander Renkl
Alexander Renkl
AEAlexander Eitel
Alexander Eitel
Summary: We investigated the processes that make seductive details (i.e., interesting but irrelevant pictures and text passages in learning materials) harmful for learning scientific concepts and principles. In our experiment, students (N = 113) learned without seductive details (control condition) or with seductive details, and afterwards worked on a knowledge test. They then retrospectively verbalized their thoughts during learning while watching a replay of their eye‐movements during the learning session (cued retrospective reporting). Our findings showed that seductive details hampered the transfer of knowledge in students with lower final school grades (d = −0.60). The verbal reports from the seductive details group, which were rated according to three detrimental cognitive processes, indicated that several students constructed mental models around the seductive details (i.e., diversion). This diversion led to worse recall of the relevant learning contents. The detrimental effects of seductive details therefore seem to be mainly caused by diversion.

4 June 2021 in Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LBLisa Bender
Lisa Bender
ARAlexander Renkl
Alexander Renkl
AEAlexander Eitel
Alexander Eitel
Background: Past research has shown that seductive details (i.e., interesting, but irrelevant adjuncts in learning materials) hamper learning in short, instructor‐paced learning sessions through impaired cognitive processing.Objectives: We integrate theory and research on multimedia learning and self‐control to test whether detrimental effects of seductive details also apply to longer and strenuous learning sessions (e.g., online lectures), in which there is greater need for self‐control.Methods: A total of N = 194 students studied five chapters in a digital learning unit about chemistry either (1) without seductive details, or (2) with seductive details but without being informed about their irrelevance for the learning goal, or (3) with seductive details while being informed about their irrelevance. To assess learning outcomes, all students completed the same posttests for recall and transfer of knowledge.Results and conclusions: For students who were uninformed about the details' irrelevance, the seductive details impeded learning outcomes not just overall, but also in the final phase of prolonged studying (i.e., when the willingness to self‐control is reduced). The latter effect was mediated through a reduced positive affect.Implications: The seductive details effect seems to generalize to prolonged learning sessions, where students may start to dislike the seductive details.

10 January 2025 in Educational Psychology Review
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
TETino Endres
Tino Endres
LBLisa Bender
Lisa Bender
SSStoo Sepp
Stoo Sepp
SZShirong Zhang
Shirong Zhang
LDLouise David
Louise David
Fred PaasFred Paas
Fred Paas
Assessing cognitive demand is crucial for research on self-regulated learning; however, discrepancies in translating essential concepts across languages can hinder the comparison of research findings. Different languages often emphasize various components and interpret certain constructs differently. This paper aims to develop a translingual set of items distinguishing between intentionally invested mental effort and passively perceived mental load as key differentiations of cognitive demand in a broad range of learning situations, as they occur in self-regulated learning. Using a mixed-methods approach, we evaluated the content, criterion, convergent, and incremental validity of this scale in different languages. To establish content validity, we conducted qualitative interviews with bilingual participants who discussed their understanding of mental effort and load. These participants translated and back-translated established and new items from the cognitive-demand literature into English, Dutch, Spanish, German, Chinese, and French. To establish criterion validity, we conducted preregistered experiments using the English, Chinese, and German versions of the scale. Within those experiments, we validated the translated items using established demand manipulations from the cognitive load literature with first-language participants. In a within-subjects design with eight measurements (N = 131), we demonstrated the scale’s criterion validity by showing sensitivity to differences in task complexity, extraneous load manipulation, and motivation for complex tasks. We found evidence for convergent and incremental validity shown by medium-size correlations with established cognitive load measures. We offer a set of translated and validated items as a common foundation for translingual research. As best practice, we recommend four items within a reference point evaluation.

29 March 2026 in British Journal of Educational Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LBLisa Bender
Lisa Bender
ARAlexander Renkl
Alexander Renkl
TETino Endres
Tino Endres
Introduction: We integrated research on instructional humour and seductive details to investigate when affiliative course‐related humour is effective or rather ineffective for learning. We assumed that instructional humour without a cognitive function (irrelevant humour) would have detrimental effects on learning performance resembling the seductive details effect, whereas humour with a cognitive function (e.g., humorous analogies illustrating the learning content) would foster performance. Methods: Our hypotheses were tested in two between‐subjects studies. Study 1 was conducted in the laboratory with 115 adults ( M age = 24.71); Study 2 was conducted in a German high school with 151 youths ( M age = 12.21). In both studies, participants learned from a narrated slideshow in one of four conditions: the slideshow either contained irrelevant humour, relevant humour, relevant (non‐humorous) examples or no additional elements (control). We then assessed learning performance, cognitive load and affective‐motivational aspects. Results: In study 1, the relevant‐humour group indeed outperformed the irrelevant‐humour group in terms of transfer. We replicated this effect in study 2 for recall performance. Our comparison to the control group without additional elements was less conclusive: The irrelevant‐humour group scored worse than the control group in study 1 (i.e., seductive details effect), but not in study 2. Moreover, the relevant‐humour group did not clearly outperform the control group in either of the studies. Conclusion: It may be safer to avoid irrelevant instructional humour (even when course‐related) because of the risk of a detrimental seductive details effect. Further research is needed with respect to the cognitive and affective‐motivational effectiveness of relevant instructional humour.

17 February 2026 in Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
LBLisa Bender
Lisa Bender
ARAlexander Renkl
Alexander Renkl
KSKatharina Scheiter
Katharina Scheiter
JRJuliane Richter
Juliane Richter
AEAlexander Eitel
Alexander Eitel
Background: According to the seductive‐details effect, practitioners should avoid interesting but irrelevant adjuncts (e.g., fun facts, comics) in learning materials as they might increase extraneous cognitive load and thus hamper learning. As the digitalisation of learning continues to increase, the question arises as to whether this recommendation also applies to interesting but irrelevant hyperlinks that are often included in online materials. Objectives: We investigated whether students perceive and use seductive details that appear behind hyperlinks differently compared to seductive details that are integrated in the learning material directly on the screen. We were assuming that students would (a) perceive hyperlink seductive details as less relevant than integrated seductive details and thus not be negatively affected in their cognitive processing (i.e., informed use of seductive details) and (b) use hyperlink seductive details to take a small break or for gratification, thereby supporting them in their persistent online learning (i.e., needs‐oriented use of seductive details). Methods: In a 3 × 2‐between‐subjects study, participants ( N = 165) worked online on a learning unit about chemistry models without seductive details or with them, either with explicit information about their irrelevance for the learning goal or without such explicit information. Moreover, we presented the details integrated in the learning material or as mouse‐over hyperlinks. Results and Conclusion: Although students perceived hyperlink seductive details as less relevant than integrated details, their learning outcomes were still impaired when they did not receive an additional explicit irrelevance instruction. Hence, our study reveals no evidence that students use seductive details via hyperlinks differently from integrated ones, but instead that seductive details via hyperlinks should also be avoided.