Lichens Go est un protocole de science participative visant à mesurer la qualité de l’air par le recensement des lichens en milieu urbain. Cet article présente une étude sociologique menée pendant une phase de test du protocole en 2017. Nous discutons ici des motivations d’implication très diverses des participants à un tel protocole et à sa phase test. Nous abordons la place que prennent les lichens dans la perception des participants de leur environnement proche à la suite de leur participation, ainsi que l’intérêt d’une telle phase de coconstruction pour ce projet de sciences participatives.
Airborne particulate matter (PM) is known to have adverse health effects and is a growing concern in urban areas. Spatial and temporal variability is difficult to assess with the few air quality stations typically available in cities. As an alternative, tree bark acts as a passive captor on which PM is deposited. Magnetic susceptibility measurements can be used as a proxy indicator to estimate pollution from vehicle sources. We present the citizen science project called Ecorc’Air, in which volunteers collect plane tree bark samples, mainly in Paris, which are then sent to laboratories and used for various measurements. The project has developed since 2016, leading to the production of annual maps that identify variations in magnetic particle concentrations. The correlation between magnetic susceptibility and metal content has been verified using multi elemental analysis. Thanks to these numerous samples, we were able to identify areas with consistently high susceptibility values over time. We also quantified the decrease in susceptibility values with the distance between the tree and the road, as well as the shielding effect of parked cars on pedestrians. We showed trends in susceptibility variations over time along a specific well‐sampled road, suggesting that this type of sampling and measurement could be used to quantify variations in metallic pollution at a local scale. Finally, through interviews, we found that there is a growing interest and participation of city dwellers, especially those involved in local associations, to act in favor of environmental research, as well as of municipalities to offer support.
1 January 2022 in Revue d'anthropologie des connaissances
Notre étude explore la co-construction d’un suivi participatif des rivières au Québec impliquant un ensemble d’acteurs, dont des volontaires. Notre analyse montre une hétérogénéité d’attentes et d’enjeux par rapport au projet de suivi participatif, même si sa finalité générale, à savoir une meilleure prévisibilité des aléas de crues, n’est pas remise en cause. Nous mettons aussi en évidence certaines tensions apparues au cours du processus, notamment autour des types de mesure et de leur mise en œuvre. Les discussions et négociations entre les acteurs autour de ces questions renvoient à des points de vue situés, propres à leur positionnement qu’elles ont participé à réaffirmer ou à transformer. Étant nous-mêmes actrices dans ce processus de co-construction, cette étude est l’occasion de mener une approche réflexive sur notre posture de chercheuses impliquées.
28 April 2025 in Citizen Science: Theory and Practice
This article presents a collective work led by researchers and project leaders in the field of citizen science (CS). Our approach is part of the “culture of error” in CS, introduced by Westreicher et al. (2021): We share our vision of the errors and difficulties we have experienced, what we have learnt from them, and what we would do differently. This work is based on ten French projects covering a variety of goals, disciplines, and the nature of the public involved. This diversity enabled us to conduct a cross-disciplinary and free-from-specificities reflection on our practices. We have identified 3 types of errors or difficulties, which we illustrate with examples drawn from our own experience. The first type of errors is the kind we would not repeat. In contrast with these “plain” mistakes, the following two types of difficulties are an invitation to defend a more realistic vision of CS. The second type refers to the uncertainties that are inherent to the plasticity of CS projects. The third are difficulties that may lead to unexpected positive consequences, both in terms of scientific objectives and community-wise. We encourage a change in the way we look at mistakes and difficulties: Uncertainty is inherent in CS and we assert our right to experiment, make mistakes, and change practices during the life of a project.