Public participation is critical to the development of urban renewal projects. This research aims to explore critical factors for successful management of public participation processes in urban renewal. Government officials and the public in China were surveyed concerning the relative importance of 30 factors identified by literature review and expert interviews. Results show that these two groups shared common perceptions and all the factors were considered critical. Factor ranking shows the top five were “the clarity of information disclosure,” “timely responses to public inquiries,” “necessary avenues and equipment,” “diversity in the ways of disclosing information,” and “results presentation.” Factor analyses reveal seven underlying components: “participant characteristics,” “participatory schemes,” “support from external sources,” “information disclosure and inquiry,” “management of participation processes,” “empowerment,” and “valuing decision information.” Those identified factors and their underlying components can help in directing resource allocation during participation for improving the management of public participation processes. Although the research setting is China, the identified factors and components are relevant to the issue of what to consider when managing a public participation process in other countries and regions, especially in situations where public participatory experience seems to be limited.
1 August 2017 in Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
This research proposes a more accurate model for assessing stakeholder-related risks by integrated analyses of risk attributes and stakeholder influences from a theoretical perspective. In the proposed model, there are three dimensions that determine risk significance (RS). The first is the risk attribute index ( ), which is related solely to the risk attributes (i.e., probability and impact). The second is the stakeholder attribute index ( ), which is related solely to the specific attributes of a stakeholder in a given project, including stakeholder salience (i.e., power, legitimacy, and urgency) and stakeholder position. The third is risk manageability ( ): a stakeholder’s capability to proactively mitigate an individual risk that they will pose (i.e., in relation to its probability or impact), which is derived from the attributes of both the stakeholder and the risk. A real-world subway project was used to test the applicability of the model. To collect data, expert judgment was elicited and the consensus of opinions was tested. Application results demonstrated the model’s capabilities in quantitatively assessing the attributes of a risk itself and the related stakeholder influences, and in prioritizing stakeholder-related risks based on their significance. Furthermore, based on the case study, a systematic process of the stakeholder-related risk management was designed for generic use and its improvements in general risk-management processes were analyzed. This study contributes to the research of risk assessment in construction projects by developing a model that is more suitable and accurate for assessing stakeholder-related risks because it incorporates previously underestimated stakeholder influences. Thus, this newly developed model improves traditional risk assessment that considers only risk attributes (i.e., probability and impact). It can also be applied to stakeholder-related risk assessment in other contexts, especially those with numerous stakeholders who pose complex risks.
1 September 2017 in Journal of Management in Engineering
Although human factors contribute greatly to accidents, a systematic examination of such factors is lacking from the literature on subway safety. The aim of this study was to analyze human safety risk factors in subway construction in China and their interactions from a broad project-stakeholder perspective. Questionnaires were used to investigate cause–effect relationships among 42 factors identified from the literature and expert interviews. Weighted-network analysis showed that accidents and safety failures resulted from strong interactions of risk factors associated with multiple stakeholders. Owners’ risk factors acted as a central risk source, amplifying risk and producing significant ripple effects on the global risk network. Many factors were associated with general contractors, but these resulted largely from risky acts by other stakeholders. These findings suggest that stakeholders should shift from separate risk mitigation to collaborative risk responses. This study improves understanding of the interactions of risk factors associated with diverse stakeholders. It also establishes a weighted-network approach to risk analysis that captures risk interactions more accurately than unweighted networks.