13 May 2019 in The Laryngoscope
8 January 2020 in The Laryngoscope
1 May 2021 in American Journal of Otolaryngology
3 March 2020 in Facial Plastic Surgery & Aesthetic Medicine
Background: Knowledge of the quality of evidence in facial plastic surgery research is essential for the implementation of evidence-based practices. The purpose of this study is to provide an update over the past decade as to whether the level of evidence in leading journals featuring topics in facial plastic surgery has changed in comparison with prior reports. Materials and Methods: This study is a systematic review, designed to evaluate the level of evidence observed in the facial plastic surgery literature over time. Five journals were queried using facial plastic surgery keywords for four selected years for a 10-year period. After screening, articles were assessed for the presence of various methodological traits and were evaluated for overall level of evidence. These variables were compared across the years studied to evaluate trends in level of evidence. Results: A total of 826 articles were included for final review. For all selected years, level IV or level V evidence was the most prevalent level of evidence. Over time, significantly less level IV ( p = 0.009) and significantly more level II ( p = 0.007) evidence was published. The proportion of studies reporting confidence intervals ( p < 0.001) and p -values ( p = 0.02) were significantly greater in later years. Conclusions: The level of evidence of facial plastic surgery literature has increased over time, as demonstrated by an increased proportion of level II evidence, decreased proportion of level IV evidence, and increased use of p -values and confidence intervals. The absolute number of randomized controlled trials continues to remain low.
1 October 2023 in OTO Open
Objective: To compare live versus delayed feedback on trainee performance of bilobe flaps using 3‐dimensional (3D)‐printed facial simulators and determine whether these effects are sustained on repeat performance.Study Design: Cohort study.Setting: University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences.Methods: 3D‐printed facial models with a nasal ala defect were provided to 18 subjects. Subjects were stratified and randomized based on their training level into 1 of 3 groups corresponding to live feedback (Group 1), delayed feedback (Group 2), and no feedback (Group 3). Subjects performed a bilobe flap following a structured lecture. Four weeks later, subjects independently repeated the exercise on the contralateral ala. Likert surveys were used to assess subjective parameters. Objective grading was performed by a plastic surgeon, which included a point system and score for the overall appearance.Results: Following exercise 1, Group 1 reported a significant improvement in knowledge (P < .001), which was sustained after exercise 2 (P < .001); Group 2 reported a significant improvement after exercise 1 (P = .03) but was not sustained (P = .435). After the second exercise, Group 1 and Group 2 improved their confidence in bilobed repair (P = .001 and P = .003, respectively), but this was greater for Group 1. Group 1 showed a significant improvement in their design time following exercise 2 (P = .007). There were no significant differences between groups on total time for repair, total score, and appearance.Conclusion: 3D‐printed models are valuable in teaching the bilobe flap for nasal defects, with live feedback providing the greatest level of improvement in self‐reported knowledge and confidence.