Bob Paap

Bob Paap

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Bob Paap

TNO, Applied Geosciences, Utrecht, The Netherlands

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

11Years (2016-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
1 January 2019 in Netherlands Journal of Geosciences
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
LBLoes Buijze
Loes Buijze
LBLonneke van Bijsterveldt
Lonneke van Bijsterveldt
HCHolger Cremer
Holger Cremer
BPBob Paap
Bob Paap
HVHans Veldkamp
Hans Veldkamp
BJBastiaan Jaarsma
Bastiaan Jaarsma
Geothermal energy is a viable alternative to gas for the heating of buildings, industrial areas and greenhouses, and can thus play an important role in making the transition to sustainable energy in the Netherlands. Heat is currently produced from the Dutch subsurface through circulation of water between two wells in deep (1.5–3 km) geothermal formations with temperature of up to ∼100 °C. As the number of these so-called doublets is expected to increase significantly over the next decades, and targeted depths and temperatures increase, it is important to assess potential show-stoppers related to geothermal operations. One of these potential hazards is the possibility of the occurrence of felt seismic events, which could potentially damage infrastructure and housing, and affect public support. Such events have been observed in several geothermal systems in other countries. Here we review the occurrence (or the lack) of felt seismic events in geothermal systems worldwide and identify key factors influencing the occurrence and magnitude of these events. Based on this review, we project the findings for seismicity in geothermal systems to typical geothermal formations and future geothermal developments in the Netherlands. The case study review shows that doublets that circulate fluids through relatively shallow, porous, sedimentary aquifers far from the crystalline basement are unlikely to generate felt seismic events. On the other hand, stimulations or circulations in or near competent, fractured, basement rocks and production and reinjection operations in high-temperature geothermal fields are more prone to induce felt events, occasionally with magnitudes ofM> 5.0. Many of these operations are situated in tectonically active areas, and stress and temperature changes may be large. The presence of large, optimally oriented and critically stressed faults increases the potential for induced seismicity. The insights from the case study review suggest that the potential for the occurrence ofM> 2.0 seismicity for geothermal operations in several of the sandstone target formations in the Netherlands is low, especially if faults can be avoided. The potential for induced seismicity may be moderate for operations in faulted carbonate rocks. Induced seismicity always remains a complex and site-specific process with large unknowns, and can never be excluded entirely. However, assessing the potential for inducing felt seismic events can be improved by considering the relevant (site-specific) geological and operational key factors discussed in this article.

15 January 2025 in Applied Ocean Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
BPBob Paap
Bob Paap
VVVincent Vandeweijer
Vincent Vandeweijer
JWJan-Diederik van Wees
Jan-Diederik van Wees
DKDirk Kraaijpoel
Dirk Kraaijpoel

5 January 2025 in Geophysics
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BBBoris Boullenger
Boris Boullenger
ABAntony Butcher
Antony Butcher
BPBob Paap
Bob Paap
VVVincent Vandeweijer
Vincent Vandeweijer
ASAnna L. Stork
Anna L. Stork
Distributed acoustic sensing (DAS) enables sampling seismic wavefields along optical fibers at a spatial resolution of less than 1 m, over distances beyond several tens of kilometers. This makes DAS a powerful tool to record seismic events densely along 2D directions, whether horizontally along the earth’s surface or vertically in boreholes. Compared with traditional seismic sensors measuring ground motion units, DAS provides uniaxial strain measurements along the fiber with often imperfectly known transfer functions between the measurements and true ground motion. This can generate uncertainties in the derivation of seismic source parameters, such as the magnitude, that require an absolute measurement of the ground motion and a known instrument response. In this study, we examine the DAS transfer function, mapping DAS data to reference velocity records obtained from multiple colocated accelerometers. Our investigation makes use of downhole recordings from the Frontier Observatory for Research in Geothermal Energy field site situated in Utah, USA. Overall, we find that the DAS response estimated at different depth positions follows a consistent trend and deviates significantly from a flat response only below 80 Hz. An average site-specific DAS system response is then used to convert microseismic event recordings into calibrated velocity records with improved amplitude accuracies. Subsequently, moment magnitudes MW are derived from the P-wave records with results matching the independent accelerometer-based estimations with high fidelity for events with MW>−1.0.

7 June 2018 in Geophysical Journal International
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
BPBob Paap
Bob Paap
DKDirk Kraaijpoel
Dirk Kraaijpoel
MBMarcel Bakker
Marcel Bakker
HGHom Nath Gharti
Hom Nath Gharti
Gas extraction from the Groningen natural gas field, situated in the Netherlands, frequently induces earthquakes in the reservoir that cause damage to buildings and pose a safety hazard and a nuisance to the local population. Due to the dependence of the national heating infrastructure on Groningen gas, the short-term mitigation measures are mostly limited to a combination of spatiotemporal redistribution of gas production and strengthening measures for buildings. All options become more effective with a better understanding of both source processes and seismic wave propagation. Detailed wave propagation simulations improve both the inference of source processes from observed ground motions and the forecast of ground motions as input for hazard studies and seismic network design. The velocity structure at the Groningen site is relatively complex, including both deep high-velocity and shallow low-velocity deposits showing significant thickness variations over relatively small spatial extents. We performed a detailed three-dimensional wave propagation modelling study for an induced earthquake in the Groningen natural gas field using the spectral-element method. We considered an earthquake that nucleated along a normal fault with local magnitude of $${{\rm{M}}_{\rm{L}}} = 3$$. We created a dense mesh with element size varying from 12 to 96 m, and used a source frequency of 7 Hz, such that frequencies generated during the simulation were accurately sampled up to 10 Hz. The velocity/density model is constructed using a three-dimensional geological model of the area, including both deep high-velocity salt deposits overlying the source region and shallow low-velocity sediments present in a deep but narrow tunnel valley. The results show that the three-dimensional density/velocity model in the Groningen area clearly play a large role in the wave propagation and resulting surface ground motions. The 3d structure results in significant lateral variations in site response. The high-velocity salt deposits have a dispersive effect on the radiated wavefield, reducing the seismic energy reaching the surface near the epicentre. In turn, the presence of low-velocity tunnel valley deposits can locally cause a significant increase in peak ground acceleration. Here we study induced seismicity on a local scale and use SPECFEM3D to conduct full waveform simulations and show how local velocity variations can affect seismic records.

1 January 2022
Verified
Conference Paper
Closed access
BPB. Paap
B. Paap
TBT. Bhakta
T. Bhakta
VVV. Vandeweijer
V. Vandeweijer
TMTrond Mannseth
Trond Mannseth

11 November 2019 in Geophysical Journal International
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BPBob Paap
Bob Paap
DKDirk Kraaijpoel
Dirk Kraaijpoel
BWBrecht Wassing
Brecht Wassing
JWJan-Diederik van Wees
Jan-Diederik van Wees
Summary: Numerical simulations of seismic wave propagation usually rely on a simple source model consisting of an idealized point location and a moment tensor. In general, this is a valid approximation when the source dimensions are small relative to the distance of points at which the seismic wave motions are to be evaluated. Otherwise, a more realistic spatio-temporal source representation is required to accurately calculate ground motions at the position of monitoring stations. Here, we present a generic approach to couple geomechanical simulations to seismic wave propagation models using the concept of the equivalent force field. This approach allows the simulation of seismic wave propagation resulting from the spatio-temporal dependent earthquake nucleation and rupture processes. Within the geomechanical package two separate geomechanics codes are used to simulate both the slow loading stage leading to earthquake nucleation as well as the successive dynamic rupture stage. We demonstrate the approach to a case of induced seismicity, where fault reactivation occurs due to production from a natural gas reservoir.