The transition toward a circular economy (CE) is key in decarbonizing the built environment. Despite this, knowledge of—and engagement with—CE philosophies remains limited within the construction industry. Discussion with practitioners reveals this to be contributed to by a lack of clarity regarding CE principles, with numerous organizations recommending implementation of differing and sometimes conflicting principles. In addition, a systematic assessment of how building designs consider CE is made difficult by the multiple design areas required to be considered and the large amount of design data required to do so. The absence of a systematic CE assessment causes a lack of comparability across designs, preventing benchmarking of CE practices in building design at present. This paper details the development of Regenerate, a CE engagement tool for the assessment of new and existing buildings, established in an effort to overcome the aforementioned barriers to the adoption of CE within the construction sector. A CE design workflow for the built environment is proposed, comprising four overarching circularity principles (Design for Adaptability; Design for Deconstructability; Circular Material Selection; Resource Efficiency) and contributing design actions. In addition to engaging stakeholders by enabling the assessment of building designs, the tool retrieves key data for further research. Information on completed design actions as well as recycling and waste metrics is collected to facilitate future CE benchmarking. “Bill of materials” data (i.e., material quantities) is also compiled, with this being key in material stock modeling research and embodied carbon benchmarking.
Buildings and construction are responsible for 38% of global greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, making decarbonisation of the construction sector essential in combatting climate change. Limiting resource consumption and waste generation by transitioning to a circular economy (CE) is key to reducing emissions. The adaptive reuse of existing buildings, such as through their vertical extension, represents one of the most effective ways in which this can be done. Despite this, and although existing work has been completed in surrounding contexts, understanding of factors influencing the uptake of vertical extensions remains limited. Through a survey and follow-up interviews, this paper investigates construction sector professionals’ current awareness, uptake and experience of vertical extensions, as well as the key drivers, barriers and enablers affecting implementation. Economic factors are revealed to be the primary driver for extension projects, though case-by-case variability results in commercial risk in some instances. Other barriers include difficulty appraising existing structures, resistance within the construction sector and unfavourable tax regimes. Mandatory whole-life carbon assessments and adjustment of tax regimes are recommended to increase uptake of vertical extensions, as well as enhanced education of engineers and greater consideration of CE amongst stakeholders.
Decarbonizing construction through a circular economy requires an in‐depth understanding of the materials stocked within, and flows into, between, and beyond, the global built environment. Archetype‐based bottom‐up material stock analysis (MSA) is increasingly used to estimate the quantity, location, and embodied carbon of different construction materials within existing buildings. European MSA studies typically employ archetypes based on building use (e.g., residential/non‐residential) and/or age (e.g., historic/modern), potentially missing significant variation in material composition across different construction types. Such work also generally focuses on residential buildings and derives aggregated and/or synthetic material intensities (MIs), with non‐residential buildings in the United Kingdom rarely being considered through real‐world design data. This paper investigates the suitability of different archetyping approaches in the bottom‐up estimation of material stocks and embodied carbon in UK buildings. Concrete is revealed to consistently contribute the majority of material mass irrespective of use or construction type, with steel consistently representing a majority of superstructural embodied carbon. Despite the relative agreement between overall structural MIs for use‐ and construction‐based archetypes, varying material and sub‐/superstructural composition introduces increased heterogeneity in individual‐material and sub‐building MIs when considering building construction type. Mapping of use‐ and construction‐based MIs to the building stock level is shown to be inhibited by the infrequent specification of construction type within the utilized inventory. This gives rise to a novel, parallel use and/or construction archetyping approach, reiterating the need for the inclusion of building construction types within both MSA archetyping approaches and national building inventories.
Reusing existing buildings is key in transitioning to a circular economy and meeting associated decarbonisation targets. Many adaptive reuse strategies, including vertical extensions, result in increased loads that need to be resisted by reserve structural capacity and/or strengthening. Previous work has identified structural under-utilisation within existing buildings and numerous sources of this have been suggested. However, understanding of associated contributions to reserve capacity and how this influences a building’s ability to be extended is limited. To address this, 11 scenarios, each modelling a different source of under-utilisation, were developed and applied in the design and reappraisal of 11 252 hypothetical steel-frame office buildings. An average reserve capacity of 10% was found in optimal Eurocode (EC) designs, rising to around 20% for British Standards and over 30% in the conservative or defensive application of ECs. Office to residential conversions were found to unlock an average reserve capacity of more than 20%. Across the 11 scenarios, 9–89% of considered cases were shown to be extendable without the need for strengthening. This demonstrates potentially significant extension potential within steel framed buildings, but that this varies with frame configuration, design/appraisal approach, and the extension’s use and structural material.
31 May 2025 in Resources, Conservation and Recycling