Juliana Otoni Parma

Juliana Otoni Parma

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Juliana Otoni Parma

Department of Kinesiology, San Francisco State University,San Francisco, CA, USA

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

10Years (2017-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
4 May 2023 in International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BMBrad McKay
Brad McKay
MBMariane F. B. Bacelar
Mariane F. B. Bacelar
JPJuliana O. Parma
Juliana O. Parma
MMMatthew Miller
Matthew Miller
MCMichael J. Carter
Michael J. Carter
Enhanced expectancies and autonomy-support through self-controlled practice conditions form the motivation pillar of OPTIMAL theory [Wulf, G., & Lewthwaite, R. (2016). Optimizing performance through intrinsic motivation and attention for learning: The OPTIMAL theory of motor learning. Psychonomic Bulletin & Review, 23(5), 1382–1414. https://doi.org/10.3758/s13423-015-0999-9]. The influence of these practice variables on motor learning was recently evaluated in two separate meta-analyses. Both meta-analyses found that the published literature suggested a moderate and significant benefit on motor learning; however, evidence for reporting bias was found in both literatures. Although multiple bias-corrected estimates were reported in the self-controlled meta-analysis, there was no principled way to prefer one over the other. In the enhanced expectancies meta-analysis, the trim-and-fill-technique failed to correct the estimated effects. Here, we addressed these limitations by reanalyzing the data from both meta-analyses using robust Bayesian meta-analysis methods. Our reanalysis revealed that reporting bias substantially exaggerated the benefits of these practice variables in the original meta-analyses. The true effects appear small, uncertain, and potentially null. We found the estimated average statistical power among all studies from the original meta-analyses was 6% (95% confidence interval [5%, 13%]). These results provide compelling and converging evidence that strongly suggests the available literature is insufficient to support the motivation pillar of OPTIMAL theory. Our results highlight the need for adequately powered experimental designs if motor learning scientists want to make evidence-based recommendations.

1 December 2021 in Motivation Science
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
BCBoris Cheval
Boris Cheval
DCDaniel A. R. Cabral
Daniel A. R. Cabral
MDMarcos Daou
Marcos Daou
MBMariane F. B. Bacelar
Mariane F. B. Bacelar
JPJuliana O. Parma
Juliana O. Parma
MMMatthew Miller
Matthew Miller

22 February 2022 in International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MBMariane F. B. Bacelar
Mariane F. B. Bacelar
JPJuliana O. Parma
Juliana O. Parma
WMWilliam (Hank) Murrah
William (Hank) Murrah
MMMatthew Miller
Matthew Miller
The OPTIMAL theory of motor learning predicts enhanced expectancies facilitate learning. This meta-analysis investigated this prediction by quantifying effect sizes from studies manipulating feedback after good trials, comparative feedback, perceived task difficulty, conceptions of ability, self-modeling, or extrinsic rewards, and assessing learning. After searching databases, 48 studies met inclusion criteria for quantitative analysis. Fifty-six effect sizes were calculated from performance differences between enhanced expectancies and neutral/diminished expectancies groups at delayed retention tests. Results revealed a Hedges’ g = 0.54 (95% CI [0.38, 0.69]) that may be overestimated due to small-study effects and underpowered studies. Moderator analyses revealed feedback after good trials, comparative feedback, perceived task difficulty, and conceptions of ability manipulations significantly improved learning. Few studies used other manipulations, precluding reliable estimates of their effects. Further, significant effects of enhanced expectancies were shown for children/adolescents, young adults, and older adults. Few studies examined special populations, preventing a reliable effect estimate. Finally, the effect of enhanced expectancies on learning was not affected by type of comparison group (neutral/diminished expectancies). Findings suggest enhanced expectancies may facilitate motor learning, consistent with OPTIMAL theory, but pre-registered/registered reports and more powerful studies should be conducted to confirm the effect and estimate its size more accurately.

1 March 2022 in Psychology of Sport and Exercise
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
MBMariane F.B. Bacelar
Mariane F.B. Bacelar
JPJuliana Otoni Parma
Juliana Otoni Parma
DCDaniel Cabral
Daniel Cabral
MDMarcos Daou
Marcos Daou
KLKeith Lohse
Keith Lohse
MMMatthew Miller
Matthew Miller

4 July 2020 in Journal of Motor Behavior
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JPJuliana Otoni Parma
Juliana Otoni Parma
VPVitor Leandro da Silva Profeta
Vitor Leandro da Silva Profeta
AAANDRE GUSTAVO PEREIRA DE ANDRADE
ANDRE GUSTAVO PEREIRA DE ANDRADE
GLGuilherme Lage
Guilherme Lage
TATércio Apolinário-Souza
Tércio Apolinário-Souza
The primary motor cortex (M1) is one of the main cortical areas involved in motor learning. However, little is known about its differential role in the learning of the relative and absolute dimensions of motor skills. We investigated the role of M1 in the learning of the dimensions of a complex motor skill. Forty-eight participants practiced golf putting and were stimulated for 20 minutes with real or sham bihemispheric tDCS before acquisition. tDCS improved global performance from pre- to post-test. Only those with worse initial performance who were stimulated by tDCS showed a significant improvement in the skill’s absolute dimension. No effects of tDCS were found for the relative dimension. Our results suggest that M1 has a distinct participation in the learning of the absolute dimension of complex motor skills, and tDCS effects are influenced by the learner’s level of initial performance.

20 June 2024 in Psychology of Sport and Exercise
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJuliana O. Parma
Juliana O. Parma
MMMatthew W. Miller
Matthew W. Miller
MBMariane F.B. Bacelar
Mariane F.B. Bacelar
Motivation is commonly recognized by researchers and practitioners as a key factor for motor learning. The OPTIMAL theory of motor learning (Wulf & Lewthwaite, 2016) claims that practice conditions that enhance learners' expectancies for future successful outcomes or that are autonomy supportive are motivating, thus leading to better learning. To examine the current evidence of the association between motivation and motor learning, we searched the literature for studies that manipulated expectancies and/or autonomy support. Specifically, our goals were to assess whether these manipulations resulted in group differences in motivation and, if so, whether increased motivation was associated with learning advantages. Results showed that out of 166 experiments, only 21% (n = 35) included at least one measure of motivation, even though this is the main factor proposed by OPTIMAL theory to explain the learning benefits of these manipulations. Among those, only 23% (n = 8) found group-level effects on motivation, suggesting that these manipulations might not be as motivating as expected. Of the eight experiments that found a group-level effect on motivation, five also observed learning benefits, offering limited evidence that when practice conditions increase motivation, learning is more likely to occur. Overall, the small number of studies assessing motivation precludes any reliable conclusions on the association between motivation and motor learning from being drawn. Together, our results question whether manipulations implemented in the research lines supporting OPTIMAL theory are indeed motivating and highlight the lack of sufficient evidence in these literatures to support that increased motivation benefits motor learning.