1 August 2024 in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
Ecosystem approaches to fisheries management are being explored worldwide, but few evaluations of multispecies harvest control rules (HCRs) exist. Our goal was to perform a simulation test of a suite of HCRs using an age-structured predator–prey model to represent the dynamics of a small pelagic fish, Atlantic menhaden ( Brevoortia tyrannus), and its predator, striped bass ( Morone saxatilis). We evaluated a suite of static and dynamic single and multispecies HCRs to estimate effects on stock performance metrics. No single HCR achieved ecosystem management objectives for both stocks given their current reference points, but HCRs that involved the “40–10 rule” for striped bass performed well across all predator performance metrics. The most influential factor determining performance of striped bass HCRs was striped bass fishing mortality, and relatively few HCRs achieved target SSB for Atlantic menhaden. Our study indicated that some HCRs recommended for forage fish management may not be effective in systems with generalist predators, and that ecosystem management objectives might be achievable by simultaneously adopting HCRs for both predator and prey stocks that complement one another.
12 May 2025 in Transactions of the American Fisheries Society
Objective: Atlantic Striped Bass Morone saxatilis are one of the most economically important fish species on the U.S. East Coast; however, trends in growth have not been recently evaluated despite concerns about the health and status of the stock. Our objective was to use otolith-aged fish from a combination of fishery-independent and fishery-dependent sources to evaluate growth of Striped Bass from 1998 to 2019 in the mid-Atlantic region of the U.S. East Coast. Methods: We used general linear models to describe temporal changes in weight at age and length at age for Striped Bass by sex and a linear mixed effects model to characterize temporal changes in Striped Bass weight at length. Results: Striped Bass length and weight at age increased primarily for ages 10–14 between 1998 and 2019 for both sexes. Increases in length at age during 1998–2019 for male Striped Bass ages 10–14 averaged 8.9 cm (±5 cm; range 0.9–14.9 cm), and female Striped Bass ages 10–15 averaged 7.8 cm (±0.5 cm; range 7.0–8.4 cm). For male and female Striped Bass ages 10–14, there was an almost 3 kg (±0.94 kg) increase in mean weight across the time series, and the percentage of change in the mean weight of males was nearly two times as great for females. Additionally, we found that female Striped Bass continued to increase in both length and weight up to ages 22 or older. The relationship between length and weight changed during 1998–2019 such that Striped Bass of a given length weighed more later in the time series. Density-dependent effects on length and weight at age were identified. Conclusions: Striped Bass of intermediate ages increased in size at age from 1998 to 2019, and female Striped Bass weight continued to accumulate through approximately age 22. The method used to age Striped Bass influenced the characterization of growth such that otolith-based weight at age is generally lower than scale-based or a mixture of scale- and otolith-based weight at age.