28 May 2026 in SSRN Electronic Journal
In vitro enzyme inhibition assays are widely used to substantiate anti-ageing and depigmentation claims for cosmetic ingredients, yet acidic formulations can suppress enzymatic activity through pH alone, independently of any active ingredient. This study evaluated the antioxidant, enzyme-inhibitory, and cytotoxic properties of three aqueous hair care formulations (HS-W, HS-W-CGO, HS-W-CG; pH 4.0–4.5) and assessed whether observed inhibition reflects genuine bioactivity or pH-mediated artefact. Total antioxidant capacity (TAC) was determined by copper-reduction colorimetry. Elastase and collagenase inhibition were evaluated with fluorescently labelled substrate kits. Human tyrosinase inhibition was assessed using a cell-lysate-derived Homo sapiens tyrosinase (hsTYR) assay with kojic acid as positive control and a pH-matched citrate buffer as vehicle control. Cytotoxicity was measured in HaCaT keratinocytes by AlamarBlue® assay at 24 h and 48 h. TAC was low across all formulations (HS-W: 23.2 ± 5.8; HS-W-CGO: 16.4 ± 7.0; HS-W-CG: 2.8 ± 1.0 µM TE), consistent with the ester-blocked activity of tocopheryl acetate. Elastase inhibition was negligible. All three formulations showed apparent collagenase (IC₅₀ ~3–4% v/v) and hsTYR inhibitory activity (IC₅₀ ~2% v/v); IC₅₀ values were indistinguishable across compositionally distinct formulations, and the citrate buffer yielded a comparable inhibitory profile, providing dual evidence for a pH-driven rather than ingredient-specific mechanism. Dose-limiting concentrations were 1.56% v/v (HS-W) and 3.13% v/v (HS-W-CGO, HS-W-CG) at 24 h. These findings demonstrate that acidic matrices generate false-positive signals in standard enzyme-based screening. pH-matched buffer controls should be mandatory, and hsTYR is recommended over mushroom-derived surrogates for translational relevance.