20 February 2022 in Analytical and Comparative Jurisprudence
It is investigated that the peculiarities of criminal responsibility and punishment of minors are its individualization, which is based on the maximum consideration of biological, psychological and social immaturity of minors. That is why the state flexibly reacts to such age peculiarities and establishes special rules of criminal-legal influence on such persons. One of the manifestations of individualization of juvenile punishment is an exhaustive list of types of punishment that can be applied to them and the terms of their execution and serving. Attention is drawn to the impossibility of imposing any of the penalties listed in the sanction due to certain age restrictions, restrictions and property status of the person. Such legal restrictions on the application of juvenile punishment lead to unfavorable conditions compared to adults who have committed the same criminal offenses, as the only possible type of punishment is imprisonment. In other cases, on the contrary, the juvenile is not subject to appropriate measures of criminal law and, accordingly, there is a situation of impunity. Thus, at the present stage of development of criminal law, the regulation of the system of juvenile punishment requires its renewal. It is investigated that in the draft Criminal Code of Ukraine the types of punishment for minors are reduced to fines, fines and imprisonment (Article 3.10.3 of the draft Criminal Code). Such a system of punishments is also not without flaws, as a person who has no income or property is sentenced to imprisonment (crimes of 1-3 degrees) (Article 3.1.7 of the draft Criminal Code "Sanctions"). Punishments such as community service, correctional labor and arrest have become part of probation. In resolving problematic issues of the application of punishment to minors, it is expedient to turn to international standards in the field of protection of the rights and freedoms of minors. International recommendations are aimed at "restricting or imprisoning a minor only as a last resort and for a minimum period" and "the need for the widest possible application of educational, labor, supervisory, educational, socially oriented, preventive non-criminal measures."
10 April 2020 in Social and Legal Studios
22 November 2025 in Uzhhorod National University Herald. Series: Law
The scientific article analyzes approaches to defining the concept of a self-interested motive in criminal offenses against property and its criminal-legal significance. In particular, attention is drawn to the fact that in the science of criminal law and in judicial practice, the prevailing position is that a self-interested motive encompasses an act aimed both at obtaining property to which the offender has no right and at evading mandatory payments from his own funds. A selfish motive is a motive for obtaining profit, a desire to enrich oneself through the commission of a criminal offense. Criminal offenses with a selfish motive can be committed directly for the benefit of the person who committed the criminal offense, as well as for the benefit of any other third parties. At the same time, it is studied that in criminal law science and judicial practice there are different approaches to the influence of a self-interested motive on the criminal-legal qualification of criminal offenses against property. One approach is that one of the tasks of modern criminal law is to protect the owner or legal user from any encroachments, regardless of the motives that guided the offender and the purpose of his activity, and the other is that the need for the presence of a self-interested motive is determined by the content of the very concept of theft as an act that is criminalized in Art. 185 of the Criminal Code, regardless of the separate indication of this motive in the content of the disposition of this article. This situation is due to the fact that the articles of Section VI of the Special Part of the Criminal Code do not provide for the motives for committing a particular criminal offense against property, including a mercenary motive. After all, the motive is an optional feature of the subjective side of the composition of a criminal offense and acts as a mandatory feature only in cases where it is directly indicated in the law or clearly follows from its content. The position is supported that the mercenary motive axiomatically follows from the analysis ofother features of the composition of criminal offenses, in particular, it is based on the content of the corresponding socially dangerous acts. In addition, such a type of punishment as confiscation of property makes it possible to attribute criminal offenses against property that are associated with theft to mercenary ones.