Natural climate solutions (NCS) could provide over one-third of the climate mitigation needed between now and 2030 to limit warming below 2°C and support the Sustainable Development Goals. However, large disparities persist between the estimated biophysical climate mitigation potential (CMP) of NCS and their actual implementation. Social, political, informational, and economic factors contribute to this gap, but the spatial distribution of these constraints and their impacts on different NCS pathways remains poorly understood. Understanding these constraints is especially important due to the large uncertainties in NCS CMP and growing research on spatial prioritization of NCS, often based only on biophysical criteria. We identified and mapped nonbiophysical constraints to NCS implementation efficacy by conducting a systematic review of recent peer-reviewed literature across 10 high-CMP NCS pathways. From 1,821 papers, we identified 352 that provided 2,480 observations of 39 unique constraints from 135 countries. We mapped the spatial distribution of these constraints and analyzed patterns across NCS pathways and geographic classifications. Lack of funding, insufficient information on NCS management, and ineffective policies emerged as the most common constraints globally. However, each pathway and geography faced a distinct suite of interrelated constraints spanning multiple categories. These findings highlight the need for context-specific, equitable solutions, likely requiring transdisciplinary approaches and cross-sectoral collaborations. The results could also help increase accuracy of NCS CMP estimates. We discuss how adaptive management may be used for NCS initiatives at any scale to proactively diagnose co-occurring constraints at each implementation phase and to develop integrated, place-based solutions.
When analyzing food systems challenges, considering multiple different narratives might lead to solutions that are more innovative and grounded in the local context relative to considering just a single narrative. However, the relationship between narrative diversity and innovation in food systems is not fully understood. Understanding the structure of and interactions between different food systems narratives can help researchers to identify opportunities (e.g., policies, interventions, and institutions) that could facilitate food systems transformations. This paper explores how narratives about food systems converge and vary between different groups of actors in rural Colombia as well as the implications for the co-development of innovative solutions amongst these actors to address food system challenges. As a case study, we focus on an important national policy initiative in Colombia, A Ciencia Cierta, which connects public science and civil society to implement community-based innovations. We conducted 47 interviews with key stakeholders, including policymakers, facilitators, academics, community leaders, and community participants who had been part of the initiative in Colombia, and experts about narratives in food systems globally. We found that actors (both individuals and groups) possess multiple narratives about food systems which evolve over time and adjust according to varying circumstances. Our findings indicate that hybrid innovations enabled by diverse knowledge(s) provide alternative solutions to overcome challenges faced by actors in food systems. This paper generates theoretical and empirical contributions to the growing study of how epistemic plurality can enhance innovation pathways in food systems.
27 November 2025 in Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems
Food systems transformations are needed to meet global climate, health, and biodiversity goals. Improving production practices, reducing food loss and waste, and shifting towards healthier diets are food system transformation strategies that could help achieve global sustainability priorities. Opportunities to advance these strategies will require considering national contexts because food systems vary substantially between countries. Little research has explored how transformations toward more sustainable food systems might manifest at the national level. Here, we use evidence from semi-structured qualitative interviews with 68 food systems experts to identify what opportunities exist at the national level for advancing food systems transformation strategies and how they are similar or different depending on the country context. We use a case study approach that compares four countries that represent a range of food systems: Brazil, Colombia, Kenya, and the United Arab Emirates (UAE). Our analysis revealed that broadly similar opportunities to address all three food system transformation strategies (improving production practices, reducing food loss and waste, shifting towards healthier diets) could be found across all four countries. However, national-level geographic and socio-economic conditions lead to differences in how similar opportunities may be most effectively implemented. Our results suggest that the national level may be an especially productive geopolitical domain for decision makers seeking to advance food system transformation efforts aligned with global targets.