Barcelona Institute for Global Health (ISGlobal), Doctor Aiguader 88, 08003 Barcelona, Spain; Universitat Pompeu Fabra (UPF), Carrer de Ramon Trias Fargas, 25-27, 08005 Barcelona, Spain; CIBER Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Monforte de Lemos, 3-5, 28029 Madrid, Spain
Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information
Georgia M.C. Dyer
Barcelona Institute for Global Health (ISGlobal), Doctor Aiguader 88, 08003 Barcelona, Spain; Universitat Pompeu Fabra (UPF), Carrer de Ramon Trias Fargas, 25-27, 08005 Barcelona, Spain; CIBER Epidemiología y Salud Pública (CIBERESP), Monforte de Lemos, 3-5, 28029 Madrid, Spain
Health Impact Assessments (HIAs) for air pollutant mixtures are challenging because risk estimates are primarily derived from single-pollutant models. Combining risk estimates from multiple pollutants requires new approaches, as a simple addition of single pollutant risk estimates from correlated air pollutants may result in double counting. We investigated approaches applying concentration-response functions (CRFs) from single- and two-pollutant models in HIAs, focusing on long-term exposure to particulate matter with a diameter less than 2.5 micrometers (PM2.5) and nitrogen dioxide (NO2) and their associations with all-cause mortality. A systematic literature search of MEDLINE and EMBASE identified cohort studies employing single- and two-pollutant models of long-term exposure to PM2.5 and NO2 with all-cause mortality. Pooled CRFs were calculated through random-effects meta-analyses of risk estimates from single- and two-pollutant models. Coefficient differences were calculated by comparing single- and two-pollutant model estimates. Four approaches to estimating population-attributable fractions (PAFs) were compared: PM2.5 or NO2 single-pollutant models to represent the mixture, the sum of single-pollutant models, the sum of two-pollutant models and the sum of single-pollutant models from a larger body of evidence adjusted by coefficient difference. Seventeen papers reported both single and two-pollutant estimates. Pooled hazard ratios (HRs) for mortality from single- and two-pollutant models were 1.053 (95% confidence interval: 1.034-1.071) and 1.035 (1.014-1.057), respectively, for a 5 μg/m3 increase in PM2.5. HRs for a 10 μg/m3 increase in NO2 were 1.032 (1.014-1.049) and 1.024 (1.000-1.049) for single- and two-pollutant models, respectively. The average coefficient difference between single- and two-pollutant models was 0.017 for PM2.5 and 0.007 for NO2. Combined PAFs for the PM2.5-NO2 mixture using joint HRs from single- and two-pollutant model CRFs were 0.09 and 0.06, respectively. Utilizing CRFs from two-pollutant models or applying the coefficient difference to a more extensive evidence base seems to mitigate the potential overestimation of mixture health impacts from adding single-pollutant CRFs.
Environmental health impact assessments (HIA)on green space, air pollution (fine particulate matter (PM2.5) or nitrogen dioxide (NO2)), and noise use exposure-response functions (ERF) based on single-exposure models from epidemiological studies, not accounting for potential confounding by other commonly correlated exposures. We assessed differences in ERFs between single- and multi-exposure models for calculation of joint health impacts in HIA. We systematically searched cohort studies that reported both single- and multi-exposure models for associations of long-term exposure to any combination of the following exposures green space, PM2.5, NO2, and noise, with all-cause mortality. For each exposure, pooled hazard ratios (HRs) were calculated by meta-analyses and compared between single- and two-exposure models. The joint effects of two exposures in each exposure pair were expressed as joint HRs calculated by multiplying the individual HRs. Coefficient differences were calculated, and population attributable fractions (PAF) were used to estimate joint health impacts. Eleven studies were identified, examining associations between multiple exposures and mortality in the general population. The studies show substantial variability in exposure levels and correlations between exposures. For most exposure pairs, adjusting for a second exposure resulted in moderately attenuated HRs compared to single-exposure models. The mortality PAFs estimated from joint single-exposure model HRs were higher than those from two-exposure models, indicating an overestimation of mortality burden when not accounting for other co-exposures. For example, when adjusted for green space or noise, the mortality HRs for PM2.5 were attenuated from 1.071 to 1.061 and 1.072 to 1.055, respectively. As for PAFs, for the green space-PM2.5 pair, the single-exposure model PAF (0.090) was 18.4% higher than the two-exposure model (0.076). For all exposure pairs, the joint PAFs of two-exposure models were higher than the PAFs from the single-exposure models for each exposure individually. The pooled coefficient differences from this study can be used to adjust single-exposure ERFs from meta-analyses and allow the calculation of combined impacts from multiple environmental exposures, making HIA estimates more robust and realistic.
Environmental Health Impact Assessments (HIAs) can inform decisions about the health effects of policy-related changes in environmental exposures. Conventional health impact metrics, focusing on mortality, morbidity, and disability, neglect subjective well-being. We explored the need and feasibility of integrating well-being indicators such as happiness and life satisfaction into quantitative environmental HIAs. Building on a multidisciplinary expert workshop and existing literature, we addressed (1) definitions and indicators of well-being, (2) pathways linking environmental exposures (air pollution, noise, extreme temperatures, and green space) to well-being, and (3) the strength of epidemiological evidence for these associations. We evaluated the challenges of integrating well-being indicators into environmental HIAs, and provided an exploratory example. We argue that including well-being in HIAs offers a more comprehensive view of health, aligning with policy goals focused on enhancing citizen's well-being. The literature identifies plausible pathways linking exposures to well-being, whilst epidemiological evidence for associations between environmental exposures and well-being is limited, but suggestive. We propose conducting exploratory HIAs integrating well-being, especially for green space (n = 16 epidemiological studies) and air pollution (n = 18). We outline two practical integration strategies: (1) report well-being impacts separately as Well-being-Adjusted Life Years, and (2) incorporate well-being into existing health indicators such as Quality-Adjusted Life Years or Disability-Adjusted Life Years. Inclusion of well-being into quantitative environmental HIAs presents a more comprehensive representation of health and well-being beyond indicators focusing on morbidity and mortality. However, the epidemiological evidence base regarding environmental exposures and well-being warrants further expansion.
Ambient air pollution is the largest environmental risk factor for morbidity and premature mortality worldwide. Studies that have quantified the health effects of air pollution typically use single-pollutant models and do not account for concurrent population exposure to other air pollutants. We compare and provide estimates of single and multi-pollutant attributable mortality for 824 European cites. We conducted quantitative single and multi-pollutant health impact assessment (HIA) to estimate the attributable mortality to PM2.5 and NO2 on adult residents (aged ≥ 20 years) in 824 European cities, in 2018. Exposure response functions from PM2.5 and NO2 single-pollutant models were adjusted by a coefficient difference approach in a multi-pollutant HIA. We quantified pollutant dominance and identified intra-city pollutant distribution patterns in relation to potential double counting and multi-pollutant burden. Non-compliance with the WHO 2021 guidelines resulted in a total of 213 889 deaths [95% CI: 89 224 - 344 223] jointly attributable to PM2.5 and NO2. This was 76 833 less deaths than the sum of single-pollutant attributable estimates (PM2.5: 145 747 [95% CI: 104 999 - 189 535]; NO2: 143 646 [95% CI: 87 398 - 198 313]). Cities with the highest multi-pollutant age-standardised attributable mortality were PM2.5 dominant, and mostly found in Eastern Europe. The majority of cities were NO2 dominant, however varied by intra-city pollutant profiles and magnitude of multi-pollutant burden. Quantifying attributable burden in a multi-pollutant HIA provides interpretable burden estimates for policy-makers and minimises potential double counting. Our findings provide critical evidence for tailoring urban and transport planning policies to city-specific contexts.