The contemporary religious landscape has seen an uptick in religious nationalism, rightist politics and other phenomena related to what prominent social thinkers Charles Taylor and Michele Dillon have called the ‘post-secular’. This article briefly summarises continuing research on such a branch of Catholic practice, known as Radical Traditionalism. Embracing pre-modern notions of ritual and related expressions of Catholicism, ‘Rad-Trads’ are increasingly vocal and present in the domains of social and political life. In this piece, the authors investigate some of the psychosocial dynamics of Rad-Trads and their implications for understanding religious strains of authoritarianism.