In order to generate proposals to strengthen environmental governance, this article studies social participation in the management of the Flora and Fauna Protection Area of the Gulf of California Islands. Based on direct observation and semi-structured interviews, the perception of public officials, specialists and users with respect to this process was analyzed in the framework of a qualitative inquiry; generating as results twenty-nine interviews with stakeholders. The main limitation for this study is the open refusal of users of this protected area to be interviewed due to the mistrust they have of public entities. The collection of experiences and perceptions of direct actors in the management of the mentioned area gives originality to this article. It is concluded that Comisión Nacional de Áreas Naturales Protegidas lacks credibility before the social organization as a result of a vertical instrumentation of its strategies without effectively considering the participation of the affected communities.
Communities' participation in the declaration and management of protected natural areas (ANP) is studied to determine whether their operation meets their inhabitants' requirements and economic needs. The research uses a quantitative approach based on applying a Likert-type survey, which was conducted on 323 fishermen and inhabitants of two fishing communities located in the Gulf of Baja, California, Mexico. The results show that interaction with government authorities is not constant, and the fishermen's opinion was not considered in decision-making, which limits the search for solutions for fishing communities. It is concluded that without the active participation and support of fishermen in the planning and operation of the ANPs, government initiatives for their conservation and good management will have little chance of being effective.