Early life survival is critical to successful replenishment of fish populations, and hypotheses developed under the Growth‐Survival Paradigm (GSP) have guided investigations of controlling processes. The GSP postulates that recruitment depends on growth and mortality rates during early life stages, as well as their duration, after which the mortality declines substantially. The GSP predicts a shift in the frequency distribution of growth histories with age towards faster growth rates relative to the initial population because slow‐growing individuals are subject to high mortality (via starvation and predation). However, mortality data compiled from 387 cases published in 153 studies (1971–2022) showed that the GSP was only supported in 56% of cases. Selection against slow growth occurred in two‐thirds of field studies, leaving a non‐negligible fraction of cases showing either an absence of or inverse growth‐selective survival, suggesting the growth‐survival relationship is more complex than currently considered within the GSP framework. Stochastic simulations allowed us to assess the influence of key intrinsic and extrinsic factors on the characteristics of surviving larvae and identify knowledge gaps on the drivers of variability in growth‐selective survival. We suggest caution when interpreting patterns of growth selection because changes in variance and autocorrelation of individual growth rates among cohorts can invalidate fundamental GSP assumptions. We argue that breakthroughs in recruitment research require a comprehensive, population‐specific characterization of the role of predation and intrinsic factors in driving variability in the distribution and autocorrelation of larval growth rates, and of the life stage corresponding to the endpoint of pre‐recruited life.
In the northern Gulf of St. Lawrence (nGSL), redfish (Sebastes mentella and Sebastes fasciatus combined) are at record levels of abundance following the strong recruitment of three consecutive cohorts in 2011–2013 and have become by far the most abundant demersal fish in the region. Understanding redfish trophic relationships is essential for the effective management and conservation of species in the nGSL ecosystem. To date, description and quantification of redfish diet in the region have been restricted to conventional stomach content analysis (SCA). Using analysis of fatty acid (FA) profiles as complementary dietary tracers, the authors conducted multivariate analyses on 350 livers of redfish which were collected in combination with stomach contents during a bottom‐trawl scientific survey in August 2017. The predator FA profiles were compared to those of eight different redfish prey types identified as dietary important with SCA. Results suggested similitude between SCA and FA results, with zooplankton prey being more related to small (<20 cm) and medium (20–30 cm) redfish (16:1n7, 20:1n?, 22:1n9 and 20:5n3) than large (≥30 cm) ones, whereas shrimp prey seemed more related to large redfish size classes (18:2n6 and 22:6n3) relative to the small and medium ones. Although the SCA offers a glimpse in the diet only based on the most recently consumed prey, analysis of FA profiles provides a mid‐term view indicating pelagic zooplankton consumption on calanoid copepod and confirming high predation pressure on shrimp. This study constitutes the first attempt of combining FA with SCA to assess the diet of redfish, highlights the benefits of FA as a qualitative tool and suggests improvements for future studies.
26 January 2013 in North American Journal of Fisheries Management
We examined the extent to which otolith microstructure provides an accurate estimate of age, growth, and early life history transitions during the period between hatching and 1 week after emergence in Brown Trout Salmo trutta exposed to natural variations in ambient water temperature. All fry analyzed possessed a prominent check on the observed date of hatching. After hatching, daily growth increments were visible on sagittal otoliths. There was no evidence for the formation of an emergence check mark and no statistically significant evidence that emergence and daily temperature fluctuations interacted to form check marks. However, daily temperature fluctuations may influence the formation of check marks, largely based on an observed increase in the proportion of fish possessing checks on the days following the two largest temperature fluctuations observed during the experiment. There was no evidence that feeding or stressing emergent fish contributed to the formation of an emergence check mark. The observed proportionality of somatic and otolith growth in conjunction with daily growth increments and the formation of a prominent hatch mark provides the opportunity to back‐calculate somatic length distributions and to document the hatching, dispersal, growth, and survival of the early life history stages of Brown Trout in nature. Received May 3, 2012; accepted October 29, 2012
1 August 2023 in Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences
Recent genomic study on Greenland halibut Reinhardtius hippoglossoides throughout the Northwest Atlantic revealed genetic differentiation between the Gulf of St. Lawrence and the remainder of the Northwest Atlantic. Knowledge of migration and thus connectivity among fish populations is key to understanding the stock dynamics of commercial species and establishing effective management strategies. In this study, we use otolith microchemistry to assess the population structure and define more clearly the potential connectivity of Greenland halibut among Saguenay Fjord, the Estuary, and the Gulf of St. Lawrence (EGSL) and outside this system. Otolith margins and cores were analyzed to determine the elemental fingerprints. The margin elemental fingerprints (Mg, Sr, and Ba) were used to infer spatial differentiation, and quadratic discriminant analysis resulted in an overall reclassification success of fish to their capture site of 59%. The core elemental fingerprints indicated three chemically distinct juvenile sources, suggesting high connectivity in the EGSL supporting the St. Lawrence Estuary as a main nursery. Our results also suggest that one of these three sources has a smaller contribution relative to the other sites.