Essential oils, hydrolates, and spagyric quintessences have been gaining prominence in healthcare. This work investigates the volatile chemical composition of these three plant-based products derived from geranium (Pelargonium graveolens), erva-baleeira (Varronia curassavica), and dentata lavender (Lavandula dentata), comparing them to support their rational use. The compositions of the essential oil, hydrolate, and spagyric quintessence were divided into three classes: oxygenated terpenes (O), monoterpene hydrocarbons (M), and sesquiterpene hydrocarbons (S). The products showed distinct compositions and proportions within these classes; the spagyric quintessence showed an intermediate volatile composition between the essential oil and hydrolate. On the other hand, the essential oil and hydrolate showed contrasting compositions. This difference indicates that the use of each product may not be directly correlated.