Anne-Marie Martindale

Anne-Marie Martindale

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Anne-Marie Martindale

Affiliation Institute of Infection, Veterinary and Ecological Sciences, University of Liverpool, Liverpool, United Kingdom

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

21Years (2006-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
18 January 2018 in BMC Medical Research Methodology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SCSarah Cotterill
Sarah Cotterill
SKSarah Knowles
Sarah Knowles
AMAnne-Marie Martindale
Anne-Marie Martindale
RERebecca Elvey
Rebecca Elvey
SHSusan Howard
Susan Howard
MSMichael Spence
Michael Spence
The Template for Intervention Description and Replication (TIDieR) checklist and guide was developed by an international team of experts to promote full and accurate description of trial interventions. It is now widely used in health research. The aim of this paper is to describe the experience of using TIDieR outside of trials, in a range of applied health research contexts, and make recommendations on its usefulness in such settings. We used the TIDieR template for intervention description in six applied health research projects. The six cases comprise a diverse sample in terms of clinical problems, population, settings, stage of intervention development and whether the intervention was led by researchers or the service deliverers. There was also variation in how the TIDieR description was produced in terms of contributors and time point in the project. Researchers involved in the six cases met in two workshops to identify issues and themes arising from their experience of using TIDieR. We identified four themes which capture the difficulties or complexities of using TIDieR in applied health research: (i) fidelity and adaptation: all aspects of an intervention can change over time; (ii) voice: the importance of clarity on whose voice the TIDieR description represents; (iii) communication beyond the immediate context: the usefulness of TIDieR for wider dissemination and sharing; (iv) the use of TIDieR as a research tool. We found TIDieR to be a useful tool for applied research outside the context of clinical trials and we suggest four revisions or additions to the original TIDieR which would enable it to better capture these complexities in applied health research:

25 January 2018 in British Journal of General Practice
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PNPauline Nelson
Pauline Nelson
AMAnne-Marie Martindale
Anne-Marie Martindale
AMAnne McBride
Anne McBride
KCKath Checkland
Kath Checkland
DHDamian Hodgson
Damian Hodgson
Faced with an ageing population living with increasingly complex health needs and a shortage of GPs and nursing staff, primary care is experiencing unprecedented pressure. Workforce transformation based around new models of care and ‘skill-mix’ change in the form of 5000 new ‘non-medical roles’ to operate alongside GPs is an aspirational solution,1 though generating the right balance of GPs/non-GPs is not without controversy.2 Although practice nurses have been working in extended roles in general practice for a long time3 there are other ‘new’ roles emerging. These encompass both the integration into primary care teams of new types of professional (for example, physician associates), and existing professional roles operating in new ways (for example, paramedics), typically with the expressed aim of releasing the capacity of GPs.4 Thus, skill-mix change may be perceived as a straightforward and common-sense response, ‘substituting’ hard-to-recruit GPs with other, non-medical, health professionals. Recently, a House of Lords Select Committee on the sustainability of the NHS has added its weight to other reports4,5 calling for the greater inclusion of non-medical workforce working under new models of care.6 Re-designing the workforce through skill-mix change is a considerable challenge for organisations, which may indeed bring benefits.5 However, the literature indicates the necessity to understand the implications of changing skill-mix if it is to deliver on its promises. Skill-mix has been conceptualised in three ways to mean: (1) the range of competencies possessed by an individual healthcare worker; (2) the ratio of senior to junior staff within a particular discipline; and (3) the mix of different types of staff in a team/healthcare setting.7 Skill-mix changes have been classified into four broad role modifications:7 enhancement (for example, extension of a primary care practice …

3 June 2019 in British Journal of General Practice
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
PNPauline A Nelson
Pauline A Nelson
FBFay Bradley
Fay Bradley
AMAnne-Marie Martindale
Anne-Marie Martindale
AMAnne McBride
Anne McBride
DHDamian Hodgson
Damian Hodgson
Background: General practice is currently facing a significant workforce challenge. Changing the general practice skill mix by introducing new non-medical roles is recommended as one solution; the literature highlights that organisational and/or operational difficulties are associated with skill-mix changes.Aim: To compare how three non-medical roles were being established in general practice, understand common implementation barriers, and identify measurable impacts or unintended consequences.Design and setting: In-depth qualitative comparison of three role initiatives in general practices in one area of Greater Manchester, England; that is, advanced practitioner and physician associate training schemes, and a locally commissioned practice pharmacist service.Method: Semi-structured interviews and focus groups with a purposive sample of stakeholders involved in the implementation of each role initiative were conducted. Template analysis enabled the production of pre-determined and researcher-generated codes, categories, and themes.Results: The final sample contained 38 stakeholders comprising training/service leads, role holders, and host practice staff. Three key themes captured participants’ perspectives: purpose and place of new roles in general practice, involving unclear role definition and tension at professional boundaries; transition of new roles into general practice, involving risk management, closing training–practice gaps and managing expectations; and future of new roles in general practice, involving demonstrating impact and questions about sustainability.Conclusion: This in-depth, in-context comparative study highlights that introducing new roles to general practice is not a simple process. Recognition of factors affecting the assimilation of roles may help to better align them with the goals of general practice and harness the commitment of individual practices to enable role sustainability.

8 November 2017 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
AMAnne-Marie Martindale
Anne-Marie Martindale
RERebecca Elvey
Rebecca Elvey
SHSusan J Howard
Susan J Howard
SMSheila McCorkindale
Sheila McCorkindale
SSSmeeta Sinha
Smeeta Sinha
TBTom Blakeman
Tom Blakeman
Objectives The study sought to examine the implementation of sick day guidance cards designed to prevent acute kidney injury (AKI), in primary care settings. Design Qualitative semistructured interviews were conducted and comparative analysis informed by normalisation process theory was undertaken to understand sense-making, implementation and appraisal of the cards and associated guidance. Setting A single primary care health setting in the North of England. Participants 29 participants took part in the qualitative evaluation: seven general practitioners, five practice nurses, five community pharmacists, four practice pharmacists, two administrators, one healthcare assistant and five patients. Intervention The sick day guidance intervention was rolled out (2015–2016) in general practices (n=48) and community pharmacies (n=60). The materials consisted of a ‘medicine sick day guidance’ card, provided to patients who were taking the listed drugs. The card provided advice about medicines management during episodes of acute illness. An information leaflet was provided to healthcare practitioners and administrators suggesting how to use and give the cards. Results Implementation of sick day guidance cards to prevent AKI entailed a new set of working practises across primary care. A tension existed between ensuring reach in administration of the cards to at risk populations while being confident to ensure patient understanding of their purpose and use. Communicating the concept of temporary cessation of medicines was a particular challenge and limited their administration to patient populations at higher risk of AKI, particularly those with less capacity to self-manage. Conclusions Sick day guidance cards that focus solely on medicines management may be of limited patient benefit without adequate resourcing or if delivered as a standalone intervention. Development and evaluation of primary care interventions is urgently warranted to tackle the harm associated with AKI.

16 March 2022 in PLOS ONE
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
ABAleksandra J. Borek
Aleksandra J. Borek
CPCaitlin Pilbeam
Caitlin Pilbeam
HMHayley Mableson
Hayley Mableson
MWMarta Wanat
Marta Wanat
PAPaul Atkinson
Paul Atkinson
STSarah Tonkin-Crine
Sarah Tonkin-Crine
Objective: To identify the experiences and concerns of health workers (HWs), and how they changed, throughout the first year of the COVID-19 pandemic in the UK. Methods: Longitudinal, qualitative study with HWs involved in patient management or delivery of care related to COVID-19 in general practice, emergency departments and hospitals. Participants were identified through snowballing. Semi-structured telephone or video interviews were conducted between February 2020 and February 2021, audio-recorded, summarised, and transcribed. Data were analysed longitudinally using framework and thematic analysis. Results: We conducted 105 interviews with 14 participants and identified three phases corresponding with shifts in HWs’ experiences and concerns. (1) Emergency and mobilisation phase (late winter-spring 2020), with significant rapid shifts in responsibilities, required skills, and training, and challenges in patient care. (2) Consolidation and preparation phase (summer-autumn 2020), involving gradual return to usual care and responsibilities, sense of professional development and improvement in care, and focus on learning and preparing for future. (3) Exhaustion and survival phase (autumn 2020-winter 2021), entailing return of changes in responsibilities, focus on balancing COVID-19 and non-COVID care (until becoming overwhelmed with COVID-19 cases), and concerns about longer-term impacts of unceasing pressure on health services. Participants’ perceptions of COVID-19 risk and patient/public attitudes changed throughout the year, and tiredness and weariness turned into exhaustion. Conclusions: Results showed a long-term impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on UK HWs’ experiences and concerns related to changes in their roles, provision of care, and personal wellbeing. Despite mobilisation in the emergency phase, and trying to learn from this, HWs’ experiences seemed to be similar or worse in the second wave partly due to many COVID-19 cases. The findings highlight the importance of supporting HWs and strengthening system-level resilience (e.g., with resources, processes) to enable them to respond to current and future demands and emergencies.

13 August 2020 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
RERebecca Elvey
Rebecca Elvey
SHSusan J Howard
Susan J Howard
AMAnne-Marie Martindale
Anne-Marie Martindale
TBThomas Blakeman
Thomas Blakeman
Objectives We sought to understand the factors influencing the implementation of a primary care intervention to improve post-discharge care following acute kidney injury (AKI). Design Qualitative study using semi-structured interviews and thematic analysis. Setting General practices in one Clinical Commissioning Group area in England. Participants A total of 18 healthcare staff took part in interviews. Participants were practice pharmacists, general practitioners, practice managers and administrators involved in implementing the intervention. Results We identified three main factors influencing implementation: differentiation of the new intervention from other practice work; development of skill mix and communication across organisations. Overall, post-AKI processes of care were deemed straightforward to embed into existing practice. However, it was also important to separate the intervention from other work in general practice. Dedicating staff time to proactively identify AKI on discharge summaries and to coordinate the provision of care enabled implementation of the intervention. The post-AKI intervention provided an opportunity for practice pharmacists to expand their primary care role. Working in a new setting also brought challenges; time to develop trusting relationships including an understanding of boundaries of clinical expertise influenced pharmacists’ roles. Unclear and inconsistent information on discharge summaries contributed to concerns about additional work in primary care. Conclusions The research highlights challenges around post-discharge management in the primary care context. Coordination and communication were key factors for improving follow-up care following AKI. Further consideration is required to understand patient experiences of the interface between secondary and primary care. The issues pertaining to discharge care following AKI are relevant to practitioners and commissioners as they work to improve transitions of care for vulnerable patient populations.