Charlotte Silén

Charlotte Silén

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Charlotte Silén

Department of Learning, Informatics, Management and Ethics (LIME), Karolinska Institutet

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

19Years (2008-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
26 June 2008 in Teaching in Higher Education
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
LULars Uhlin
Lars Uhlin
Self-directed learning (SDL), is an essential concept in problem-based learning (PBL), and, in a broader sense, student-centred learning. Considering the complex nature of SDL, it has been taken for granted and given a shallow meaning, i.e. self-study. In order to develop a deeper understanding and make use of the potential in SDL, this paper discusses and puts forward a more profound meaning. The importance of regarding becoming a self-directed learner as a learning process, and the need for teachers to take part in the learning, is crucial. Two ‘thinking models’, one concerning the PBL tutorial work and one the relationship between tutorial work and self-study, are introduced. The unifying idea behind the reasoning is to emphasise the essence of providing opportunities for, as well as stimulating, the students’ inquiring approach and responsibility.

22 June 2020 in Journal of Evaluation in Clinical Practice
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CKCharilaos Koufidis
Charilaos Koufidis
KMKatri Manninen
Katri Manninen
JNJuha Nieminen
Juha Nieminen
MWMartin Wohlin
Martin Wohlin
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
Rationale: Clinical reasoning lies at the heart of medical practice and has a long research tradition. Nevertheless, research is scattered across diverse academic disciplines with different research traditions in a wide range of scientific journals. This polyphony is a source of conceptual confusion.Aims and objectives: We sought to explore the underlying theoretical assumptions of clinical reasoning aiming to promote a comprehensive conceptual and theoretical understanding of the subject area. In particular, we asked how clinical reasoning is defined and researched and what conceptualizations are relevant to such uses.Methods: A scoping review of the clinical reasoning literature was undertaken. Using a “snowball” search strategy, the wider scientific literature on clinical reasoning was reviewed in order to clarify the different underlying conceptual assumptions underlying research in clinical reasoning, particularly to the field of medical education. This literature included both medical education, as well as reasoning research in other academic disciplines outside medical education, that is relevant to clinical reasoning. A total of 124 publications were included in the review.Results: A detailed account of the research traditions in clinical reasoning research is presented. In reviewing this research, we identified three main conceptualisations of clinical reasoning: “reasoning as cognitive activity,” “reasoning as contextually situated activity,” and “reasoning as socially mediated activity.” These conceptualisations reflected different theoretical understandings of clinical reasoning. Each conceptualisation was defined by its own set of epistemological assumptions, which we have identified and described.Conclusions: Our work seeks to bring into awareness implicit assumptions of the ongoing clinical reasoning research and to hopefully open much needed channels of communication between the different research communities involved in clinical reasoning research in the field.

3 June 2015 in BMC Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SKSusanne Kalén
Susanne Kalén
SPSari Ponzer
Sari Ponzer
ASAstrid Seeberger
Astrid Seeberger
AKAnna Kiessling
Anna Kiessling
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
Mentoring has been employed in medical education in recent years, but there is extensive variation in the published literature concerning the goals of mentoring and the role of the mentor. Therefore, there is still a need for a deeper understanding of the meaning of mentoring for medical students’ learning and development. The aim of this qualitative study is to explore how formal and longitudinal mentoring can contribute to medical students’ professional development. Sixteen medical students at a Swedish university were interviewed individually about their experiences of combined group and one-to-one mentoring that is given throughout their studies. The mentoring programme was focused on the non-medical skills of the profession and used CanMEDS roles of a physician for students’ self-assessment. Data were analysed using a latent, interpretive approach to content analysis. The results comprise three themes: Integrating oneself with one’s future role as a physician, Experiencing clinical reality with the mentor creates incentives to learn and Towards understanding the professional competence of a physician. The mentorship enabled the students to create a view of their future professional role and to integrate it with their own personalities. The students’ understanding of professional competence and behaviour evolved during the mentorship and they made advances towards understanding the wholeness of the profession. This approach to mentorship supported different components of the students’ professional development; the themes Integrating oneself with one’s future role and Towards understanding the professional competence of a physician can be regarded as two parallel processes, while the third theme, Experiencing clinical reality with the mentor creates incentives to learn, promotes these processes. Formalized and longitudinal mentoring focusing on the non-medical skills can be recommended to help medical students to integrate their professional role with themselves as individuals and promote understanding of professional competence in the process of becoming a physician.

5 November 2015 in BMC Nursing
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
KMKatri Manninen
Katri Manninen
EHElisabet Welin Henriksson
Elisabet Welin Henriksson
MSMax Scheja
Max Scheja
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
Clinical practice is essential for health care students. The supervisor’s role and how supervision should be organized are challenging issues for educators and clinicians. Clinical education wards have been established to meet these challenges and they are units with a pedagogical framework facilitating students’ training in real clinical settings. Supervisors support students to link together theoretical and practical knowledge and skills. From students’ perspectives, clinical education wards have shown potential to enhance students’ learning. Thus there is a need for deeper understanding of supervisors’ pedagogical role in this context. We explored supervisors’ approaches to students’ learning at a clinical education ward where students are encouraged to independently take care of patients. An ethnographic approach was used to study encounters between patients, students and supervisors. The setting was a clinical education ward for nursing students at a university hospital. Ten observations with ten patients, 11 students and five supervisors were included in the study. After each observation, individual follow-up interviews with all participants and a group interview with supervisors were conducted. Data were analysed using an ethnographic approach. Supervisors’ pedagogical role has to do with balancing patient care and student learning. The students were given independence, which created pedagogical challenges for the supervisors. They handled these challenges by collaborating as a supervisory team and taking different acts of supervision such as allowing students their independence, being there for students and by applying patient-centredness. The supervisors’ pedagogical role was perceived as to facilitate students’ learning as a team. Supervisors were both patient- and student-centred by making a nursing care plan for the patients and a learning plan for the students. The plans were guided by clinical and pedagogical guidelines, individually adjusted and followed up.

1 May 2021 in Medical Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
CKCharilaos Koufidis
Charilaos Koufidis
KMKatri Manninen
Katri Manninen
JNJuha Nieminen
Juha Nieminen
MWMartin Wohlin
Martin Wohlin
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
Background: All thinking occurs in some sort of context, rendering the relation between context and clinical reasoning a matter of significant interest. Context, however, has a notoriously vague and contested meaning. A profound disagreement exists between different research traditions studying clinical reasoning in how context is understood. However, empirical evidence examining the impact (or not) of context on clinical reasoning cannot be interpreted without reference to the meaning ascribed to context. Such meaning is invariably determined by assumptions concerning the nature of knowledge and knowing. The epistemology of clinical reasoning determines in essence how context is conceptualised. Aims: Our intention is to provide a sound epistemological framework of clinical reasoning that puts context into perspective and demonstrates how context is understood and researched in relation to clinical reasoning. Discussion: We identify three main epistemological dimensions of clinical reasoning research, each of them corresponding to fundamental patterns of knowing: the representational dimension views clinical reasoning as an act of categorisation, the interactional dimension as a cognitive state emergent from the interactions in a system, while the interpretative dimension as an act of intersubjectivity and socialisation. We discuss the main theories of clinical reasoning under each dimension and consider how the implicit epistemological assumptions of these theories determine the way context is conceptualised. These different conceptualisations of context carry important implications for the phenomenon of context specificity and for learning of clinical reasoning. Conclusion: The study of context may be viewed as the study of the epistemology of clinical reasoning. Making sense of ‘what is going on with this patient’ necessitates reading the context in which the encounter is unfolding and deliberating a path of response justified in that specific context. Mastery of the context in this respect becomes a core activity of medical practice.

24 January 2023 in Anatomical Sciences Education
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
APAnna Frideborg Pettersson
Anna Frideborg Pettersson
KKKlas Karlgren
Klas Karlgren
JAJonathan Al‐Saadi
Jonathan Al‐Saadi
HHHans Hjelmqvist
Hans Hjelmqvist
BMBjörn Meister
Björn Meister
CSCharlotte Silén
Charlotte Silén
Learning anatomy holds specific challenges, like the appreciation of three‐dimensional relationships between anatomical structures. So far, there is limited knowledge about how students construct their understanding of topographic anatomy. By understanding the processes by which students learn anatomical structures in 3D, educators will be better equipped to offer support and create successful learning situations. Using video analysis, this study investigates how students discern anatomical structures. Sixteen students at different levels of education and from different study programs were recorded audiovisually while exploring 3D digital images using a computerized visualization table. Eleven hours of recorded material were analyzed using interaction analysis and phenomenography. Seven categories were identified during data analysis, describing the qualitatively different patterns of actions that students use to make sense of anatomy: decoding the image; positioning the body in space; purposeful seeking, using knowledge and experience; making use of and creating variation; aimless exploration, and arriving at moments of understanding. The results suggest that anatomy instruction should be organized to let the students decide how and at what pace they examine visualized images. Particularly, the discovery process of decoding and positioning the body in space supports a deep learning approach for learning anatomy using visualizations. The students' activities should be facilitated and not directed.