19 October 2018 in Biological Reviews
14 August 2024 in Proceedings Of The Royal Society B-Biological Sciences
The separation of closely related terrestrial or freshwater species by vast marine barriers represents a biogeographical riddle. Such cases can provide evidence for vicariance, a process whereby ancient geological events like continental rifting divided ancestral geographical ranges. With an evolutionary history extending tens of millions of years, freshwater ecology, and distribution encompassing widely separated southern landmasses, osteoglossid bonytongue fishes are a textbook case of vicariance attributed to Mesozoic fragmentation of the Gondwanan supercontinent. Largely overlooked fossils complicate the clean narrative invoked for extant species by recording occurrences on additional continents and in marine settings. Here, we present a new total-evidence phylogenetic hypothesis for bonytongue fishes combined with quantitative models of range evolution and show that the last common ancestor of extant osteoglossids was likely marine, and that the group colonized freshwater settings at least four times when both extant and extinct lineages are considered. The correspondence between extant osteoglossid relationships and patterns of continental fragmentation therefore represents a striking example of biogeographical pseudocongruence. Contrary to arguments against vicariance hypotheses that rely only on temporal or phylogenetic evidence, these results provide direct palaeontological support for enhanced dispersal ability early in the history of a group with widely separated distributions in the modern day.
13 May 2020 in Royal Society Open Science
Many modern groups of marine fishes first appear in the fossil record during the early Palaeogene (66–40 Ma), including iconic predatory lineages of spiny-rayed fishes that appear to have originated in response to ecological roles left empty after the Cretaceous/Palaeogene extinction. The hypothesis of extinction-mediated ecological release likewise predicts that other fish groups have adopted novel predatory ecologies. Here, we report remarkable trophic innovation in early Palaeogene clupeiforms (herrings and allies), a group whose modern representatives are generally small-bodied planktivores. Two forms, the early Eocene (Ypresian) †Clupeopsisfrom Belgium and a new genus from the middle Eocene (Lutetian) of Pakistan, bear conspicuous features indicative of predatory ecology, including large size, long gapes and caniniform dentition. Most remarkable is the presence of a single, massive vomerine fang offset from the midline in both. Numerous features of the neurocranium, suspensorium and branchial skeleton place these taxa on the engraulid (anchovy) stem as the earliest known representatives of the clade. The identification of large-bodied, piscivorous anchovies contributes to an emerging picture of a phylogenetically diverse guild of predatory ray-finned fishes in early Palaeogene marine settings, which include completely extinct lineages alongside members of modern marine groups and taxa that are today restricted to freshwater or deep-sea environments.
24 September 2025 in Systematic Biology
Phylogenetic tip-dating has been and still is revolutionizing evolutionary biology in several ways. Fossil tip-dating, where fossils are placed into a phylogeny as tips based on morphological and/or molecular character information, provides a more principled approach to infer time-calibrated phylogenies compared with node-dating. Additionally, phylogenetic trees with fossils as tips become more and more important to elucidate evolutionary processes in macroevolutionary studies (e.g., deciphering diversification patterns and directional phenotypic evolution). Fossil tip-dating is slowly gathering popularity in empirical applications and has progressed substantially since its first demonstration in 2011, with respect to improved statistical models, software, and data sets. Nevertheless, executing a phylogenetic fossil tip-dating analysis is complicated and comes with many challenges. Here, we provide an extensive review and overview of methods and models for phylogenetic tip-dating analyses with fossils. We focus both on data collection and preparation and on modeling choices. We start with a survey of all published phylogenetic tip-dating studies to date, showing common data and modeling choices as well as trends toward new approaches. Then, we walk readers through sections of molecular evolution, morphological evolution (both for discrete and continuous data), and lineage evolution (the fossilized birth–death process). In each section, we describe the data and standard models with their underlying assumptions, and provide an outlook and practical recommendations.
16 May 2025 in Systematic Biology
Models used in likelihood-based morphological phylogenetics often adapt molecular phylogenetics models to the specificities of morphological data. Such is the case for the widely used Mkv model—which introduces an acquisition bias correction for sampling only characters that are observed to be variable—and for models of among-character rate variation (ACRV), routinely applied by researchers to relax the equal-rates assumption of Mkv. However, the interaction between variable character acquisition bias and ACRV has never been explored before. We demonstrate that there are two distinct approaches to condition the likelihood on variable characters when there is ACRV, and we call them joint and marginal acquisition bias. Far from being just a trivial mathematical detail, we show that the way in which the variable character conditional likelihood is calculated results in different assumptions about how rate variation is distributed in morphological data sets. Simulations demonstrate that tree length and amount of ACRV in the data are systematically biased when conditioning on variable characters differently from how the data were simulated. Moreover, an empirical case study with extant and extinct taxa reveals a potential impact not only on the estimation of branch lengths, but also of phylogenetic relationships. We recommend the use of the marginal acquisition bias approach for morphological data sets modeled with ACRV. Finally, we urge developers of phylogenetic software to clarify which acquisition bias correction is implemented for both estimation and simulation, and we discuss the implications of our findings on modeling variable characters for the future of morphological phylogenetics.