This study aims to investigate Arabic phonological errors in daily prayer recitations, analyze fossilization patterns, and examine their implications for the validity of worship at Dayah Darul Aitami, West Aceh. Employing a qualitative field design, data were collected from female students (santriwati) serving as prayer leaders via observation-recording techniques, in-depth interviews, and document analysis. Data were analyzed using Corder’s Error Analysis procedure and juxtaposed with Shafi’i jurisprudence (fiqh). The findings indicate systematic fossilization of phonological errors across 14 primary points of articulation. Two patterns dominate: a shift from pharyngeal to glottal sounds (e.g., ḥā’ to hā’) and a change from uvular fricatives to plosives (e.g., khā’ to qāf). Semantic analysis demonstrates that these errors constitute laḥn jalī, significantly distorting theological meaning due to mother-tongue interference and minimal corrective feedback. Consequently, this study recommends pedagogical reform through intensive talaqqī methods and articulatory phonetics to safeguard liturgical validity.