Reconciling community development and biodiversity conservation is essential for fostering mutually beneficial relationships between land reform beneficiary communities and protected areas in rural South Africa. Following apartheid, some communities that successfully reclaimed their ancestral land entered into co-management agreements with conservation authorities to retain these areas as protected landscapes. While land restitution has restored ownership rights and created livelihood opportunities through conservation and ecotourism, persistent concerns remain regarding power relations, benefit distribution, and meaningful participation in decision-making. Using the Double Drift Nature Reserve (DDNR), a 23,500-ha protected area within the Great Fish River Nature Reserve, as a case study, this research evaluates the effectiveness of comanagement and benefit-sharing arrangements between the Eastern Cape Parks and Tourism Agency (ECPTA) and the Likhayalethu Communal Property Association (LCPA). Data were collected through 23 semi-structured interviews with current and former LCPA executive members, land claimants, and community members from Gxwederha, Kwa Jani, Glenmore, Qamnyana, Khayamnandi, Alice, and King William's Town. The findings indicate that the land restitution process has successfully restored land ownership to claimant communities. However, despite formal co-management arrangements, perceived inequities in power, influence, and decision-making continue to undermine the effectiveness and legitimacy of shared governance. These inequities appear to stem from a mismatch between community expectations and ECPTA institutional policies, resulting in unequal access to conservation-related benefits. The study highlights the gap between the formal objectives of co-management and their practical implementation, demonstrating that equitable governance and meaningful community participation are essential for achieving both conservation and rural development outcomes.