27 February 2025 in British Educational Research Journal
Teacher retention in England continues to be in a state of decline, with early career teachers (ECTs) most at risk of leaving the profession. High attrition rates create an unstable and unsustainable workforce, which negatively affects the educational development of young people. The purpose of this paper was to explore the career‐related push and pull factors for ECTs in England. The paper also explores the way in which ECTs' experiences shape career decision‐making, and the extent to which their motivational needs are being met. Previous studies have considered workplace retention; however, little is known about the motivational needs and perspectives of ECTs. This paper explores the experiences of 20 ECTs in state‐funded primary, secondary and special schools in England. All participants had less than 5 years' teaching experience and were selected through purposive sampling. Participants took part in semi‐structured online interviews with data analysed using reflexive thematic analysis. Five themes were constructed from the data: complexity, belonging, emotional impact, professional identity and relentlessness. Findings show that these themes are interrelated and combine to create a clear ‘tipping point’ where ECTs begin to find the job unmanageable. From a motivation perspective, we found that autonomous motivation reduces quitting intentions and that the need for relatedness and positive professional identities is particularly important for retaining teachers in the first 5 years of their careers.
1 September 2025 in Computers & Education
5 December 2024 in European Journal of Education
The recruitment of undergraduate students in England into teacher education is a recognised challenge with recruitment targets having been missed in nine of the last 10 years. The recruitment shortfalls are most acute within STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) subjects. This qualitative study explores which aspects of teaching attract and deter undergraduate STEM students from entering the profession, and which aspects of the vocation are unknown to undergraduates. Participants consisted of 267 STEM undergraduate students (73% White British; 57% female) from a broad range of UK universities. The sample reflected the sociodemographic characteristics (e.g., ethnicity, gender, socioeconomic background [SEB]) of undergraduate students in British universities. Data for this study consisted of responses to open‐ended questions about interest in teaching generated after exposure to an experimental vignette intervention consisting of 12 teaching‐related vignettes, each exhibiting a different motivation for entering teaching. Data were coded using reflexive thematic analysis and multiple indexing. Findings from this study suggested that participants were primarily attracted to teaching by the perceived emotional rewards of supporting young people, and the tangible benefits (e.g., holidays) made the career desirable. However, participants also felt an imbalance between the pull and push factors of teaching. Workload and negative treatment of teachers were seen as the central deterrents to entering teaching; however, we also found that there was a significant knowledge deficit about what teaching entails.
7 October 2025 in British Educational Research Journal
The current study provides an understanding of career‐related motivations of 16–19‐year‐olds in schools and A‐level colleges in England and Wales. The 672 participants (62% women) were asked to complete a modified version of the Motivations for Career Choice and the Persistence Research in Science and Engineering scales and provide comments on their perceptions of teaching as a career. Results showed that participants were most interested in entrepreneurial and technology‐related careers, although results varied by gender, ethnicity and subject area focus (i.e., STEM vs non‐STEM). Mean interest in teaching was low (2.87 on a seven‐point scale), with a teaching career rated as the least preferred career option (of eight options) by men, ethnic minorities and STEM students. Intrinsic motivations, such as matching personal interests and the potential for excitement, were the most important factors when choosing a career. The prospect of working with children and adolescents and the influence of friends were rated as the least important motivators for our sample. Our results suggest that young people's preferred career motivations do not often align with the motivations associated with a teaching career. We did, however, identify subsets of our sample where the motivations for teaching as a career were stronger. We conclude by offering recommendations about teacher recruitment interventions that dispel some of the misconceptions young people hold about teaching.
5 October 2025 in Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction
Persuasive games, designed to change attitudes and inspire behavior change, have attracted significant interest. In particular, persuasive recruitment games are increasingly in demand due to under recruitment in many occupations. However, research on persuasive games often lacks clear design guidance and tends to focus on individual player experience factors, rather than identifying and prioritizing the most influential ones that should shape design decisions. Our study (n = 957) examined how player experience impacts recruitment interventions aimed at encouraging careers in teaching. We compared three approaches; a persuasive game, a “realistic job preview” (RJP) and a control game. Effectiveness was measured by increases in Interest (in teaching), Person-vocation (PV) fit and Self-efficacy. Results showed that the persuasive game was the most effective at increasing Interest, while the RJP had the greatest impact on PV fit and Self-efficacy. Interest was primarily influenced by experiences of meaning, followed by mastery. Conversely, mastery followed by meaning were the strongest influences on PV fit and Self-efficacy. Experiences of immersion or autonomy had no significant effect on persuasion. We discuss how understanding which aspects of game experience have most impact can aid the design of persuasive games for recruitment and other purposes.
3 April 2026 in Journal of Visual Literacy