Judith Smith

Judith Smith

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Judith Smith

Health Services Management Centre, University of Birmingham, Birmingham, UK

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

27Years (2000-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
29 October 2021 in International Journal of Integrated Care
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
RLRichard Q. Lewis
Richard Q. Lewis
KCKath Checkland
Kath Checkland
MDMary Alison Durand
Mary Alison Durand
TLTom Ling
Tom Ling
NMNicholas Mays
Nicholas Mays
JSJudith A. Smith
Judith A. Smith
For more than a decade the English NHS has pursued integrated care through three national pilot programmes. The independent evaluators of these programmes here identify several common themes that inform the development of integrated care. The three pilot programmes shared the aim of better coordination between hospital and community-based health services and between health and social care. Each programme recruited local pilot sites that designed specific interventions to support inter-professional and inter-organisational collaboration. The pilots were highly heterogenous and results varied both within and between the three programmes. While staff were generally positive about their achievements, pilots had mixed success especially in reducing unplanned hospital admissions. Common facilitators to achieving pilots’ objectives included effective senior leadership and shared values, simple interventions and additional funding. Barriers included short timescales, poor professional engagement, information and data sharing problems, and conflicts with changing national policy. There was little stable or shared understanding of what ‘integrated care’ meant resulting in different practices and priorities. An increasing focus on reducing unplanned hospital use among national sponsors created a mismatch in expectations between local and national actors. Pilots in all three national programmes made some headway against their objectives but were limited in their impact on unplanned hospital admissions.

8 December 2005 in BMJ
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JSJudith Smith
Judith Smith
JDJennifer Dixon
Jennifer Dixon
NMNicholas Mays
Nicholas Mays
HMHugh McLeod
Hugh McLeod
NGNick Goodwin
Nick Goodwin
SWSally Wyke
Sally Wyke
General practitioners are being asked to retake responsibility for commissioning healthcare services. What can we learn from previous experience?

30 December 2021 in BMJ Open
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
SPSarah Parkinson
Sarah Parkinson
JSJudith Smith
Judith Smith
MSManbinder Sidhu
Manbinder Sidhu
Objectives Primary care networks (PCNs) were introduced in the National Health Service (NHS) in England in 2019 to improve integrated care for patients and help address financial and workforce sustainability issues in general practice. The purpose of this study was to collect early evidence on their implementation and development, including motivations to participate and what enables or inhibits progress. This paper considers the core characteristics of PCNs, and how this informs their management. Design A qualitative mixed-methods rapid evaluation was conducted across four case study sites in England, informed by a literature review and stakeholder workshop. Data collection comprised interviews, non-participant observation of meetings, an online survey and documentary review. Results General practitioners (GPs) are motivated to participate in PCNs for their potential to improve patient care, enable better coordinated services and enhance financial and workforce sustainability within primary care. However, PCNs also have an almost mandatory feel, based on the national policy context and significant financial incentives associated with joining them. PCNs offer potential to bring GPs together to work towards common goals, deliver national priorities and respond rapidly to local needs. Conclusions PCNs face similar challenges to other meso-level primary care organisations internationally, as they respond to local and national priorities and operate in a context of multiple goals and interests. In managing these organisations, it is important to find a balance between local and national autonomy, decision making and control.

1 July 2023 in Health and Social Care Delivery Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JSJudith Smith
Judith Smith
JEJo Ellins
Jo Ellins
CSChris Sherlaw-Johnson
Chris Sherlaw-Johnson
CVCecilia Vindrola-Padros
Cecilia Vindrola-Padros
JAJohn Appleby
John Appleby
NFNaomi J Fulop
Naomi J Fulop
This essay explores the emerging field of rapid evaluation in health and social care, drawing out the ways in which it is distinctive from or similar to other forms of applied research. It draws closely on the experience of two National Institute for Health and Care Research rapid service evaluation teams established in 2018, of which all authors of this essay are members. Reflection on the rapid evaluation teams’ body of work is used to highlight methodological and operational considerations for researchers, practitioners and policy-makers interested in the commissioning, conduct and application of rapid evaluations in health and social care. The essay is organised according to the ‘evaluation pathway’, from project selection and scoping, stakeholder involvement, research methods and activity, through skills and team working to feedback and dissemination. Its conceptual framing draws on Riley et al.’s rapidity, responsiveness and relevance framework, proposing a fourth dimension of rigour. Novel insights include: the primacy of scoping thoroughly a rapid evaluation; the trade-offs to be made in respect of patient and community engagement and rapid working; the opportunities presented by virtual and mixed research methods; the particular challenges of supervising and leading multiple studies undertaken simultaneously; and the need for flexible and dynamic approaches to disseminating emerging findings in as close to real time. The essay concludes by setting out key lessons about how to conduct rapid evaluations. Funding: This project was funded by the National Institute for Health and Care Research (NIHR) Health and Social Care Delivery Research programme (RSET: 16/138/17; BRACE: 16/138/31).

15 April 2019 in BMC Health Services Research
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
PDF file
JSJudith Smith
Judith Smith
GWGerald Wistow
Gerald Wistow
HHHolly Holder
Holly Holder
MGMatthew Gaskins
Matthew Gaskins
Commissioning is a term used in the English National Health Service (NHS) to refer to what most health systems call health planning or strategic purchasing. Drawing on research from a recent in-depth mixed methods study of a major integrated care initiative in North West London, we examine the role of commissioning in attempts to secure large-scale change within and between health and social care services to support the delivery of integrated care for people living with complex long-term conditions. We analysed data collected in semi-structured interviews, surveys, workshops and non-participant observations using a thematic framework derived both deductively from the literature on commissioning and integrated care, as well as inductively from our coding and analysis of interview data. Our findings indicate that commissioning has significant limitations in enabling large-scale change in health services, particularly in engaging providers, supporting implementation, and attending to both its transactional and relational dimensions. Our study highlights the consequences of giving insufficient attention to implementation, and especially the need for commissioners to enable, support and performance manage the delivery of procured services, while working closely with providers at all times. We propose a revised version of Øvretveit’s cycle of commissioning that gives greater emphasis to embedding effective implementation processes within models of commissioning large-scale change.

23 January 2007 in The International Journal of Health Planning and Management
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
PDF file
JSJudith Smith
Judith Smith
NMNicholas Mays
Nicholas Mays