Soil nitrogen (N) cycling shapes forest productivity, carbon storage, and greenhouse gas emissions, making it critical to ecosystem functioning and climate mitigation. As afforestation expands as a natural climate solution, understanding legacy effects on soil N cycling is essential. We compared soil N transformation rates across 73 broadleaf and conifer stands distributed across the southeastern US in a controlled laboratory incubation study. We measured rates of ammonification (Namm), nitrification (Nnit), and mineralization (Nmin) in a laboratory incubation study and compared these rates to soil physiochemical properties and forest structural characteristics. In broadleaf stands, Namm rates were balanced (-0.443 ± 1.062 µg N g soil-1d-1), while in conifer stands Namm rates were negative (-3.828 ± 1.640 µg N g soil-1d-1). Both forest types had positive Nnit rates, but conifer stand rates were 1.6 times greater (9.417 ± 1.221 vs. 5.770 ± 0.504 µg N g soil-1d-1; p = 0.006). Net Nmin rates were positive and did not differ significantly between forest types. In both systems, Namm was correlated with forest structural properties. In broadleaf stands, Nnit was only correlated with soil physiochemical properties (bulk density, carbon, nitrogen) while in conifer stands Nnit was correlated with both forest structure (leaf area, basal area) and soil physiochemical properties (carbon, nitrogen, pH). These findings demonstrate that N cycling responses to afforestation vary by forest type and are jointly regulated by vegetation structure and soil physiochemical properties. Understanding these controls is essential for predicting nutrient availability and optimizing the ecological benefits of large-scale afforestation efforts.