We developed a diatom-based index that integrates the effects of multiple stresses on streams and provides information related to the "distance" from the nonimpacted state. The Eastern Canadian Diatom Index (IDEC) was based on a correspondence analysis (CA) to develop a chemistry-free index where the position of the sites along the gradient of maximum variance (first axis) is strictly determined by diatom community structure and is therefore independent of measured environmental variables. The index value indicates the distance of each diatom community from its specific reference community. A high index value represents a non- or less-impacted site, while a low index value represents a more heavily impacted site. Two sub-indices were developed based on two sets of reference communities. The IDEC-circumneutral includes the sites that have reference communities characteristic of slightly acidic or neutral environments. The IDEC-alkaline includes the sites that have reference communities characteristic of environments where pH values are naturally higher than 7.5. The distinction between the two sub-indices is fundamental to make sure that each stream has the potential to reach a high IDEC value following complete restoration of its ecosystem.
The identification of biological reference conditions specific to each type of water body is essential for the development of sound biological indicators and criteria. The purpose of the present study was to establish the reference conditions of each stream type sampled in southern Québec (Canada) using benthic diatoms and environmental variables characterizing streams and watersheds. First, stream reaches were classified as a function of their natural watershed and habitat characteristics. Second, diatom communities were classified based solely on taxa abundance data. Resulting groups were graphically presented on ordinations to interpret, a posteriori, the environmental gradients associated with diatom groups and to identify the diatom communities representing the reference conditions of each of the stream reach groups. A final classification based solely on diatom reference communities found pH and conductivity to be the main discriminating factors, regardless of ecoregion and stream type. Although a specific diatom reference community may be identified for each stream group, our results suggest that many of these communities exhibit strong similarities. Only two reference communities may therefore be used, one for circumneutral conditions and one for alkaline conditions. These reference communities represent the baseline for biocriteria development.