Jan Perret

Jan Perret

Auto-generated profile, based on publicly available information

Jan Perret

CEFE, Univ Montpellier, CNRS, EPHE‐PSL University, IRD Montpellier France

Research Focus & Metrics

Academic Career Length

5Years (2022-Present)

(Calculated once Scilit publication data is synced: current year − year of first publication + 1)

Representative Publications

View All Publications
3 November 2022 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
ACAnne Charpentier
Anne Charpentier
RPRoger Pradel
Roger Pradel
GPGuillaume Papuga
Guillaume Papuga
ABAurélien Besnard
Aurélien Besnard
Population size is a crucial parameter for both ecological research and conservation planning. When individuals are aggregated, estimating the size of a population through sampling raises methodological challenges, as the high variance between sampling units leads to imprecise estimates. Choosing the right sample design depending on the population aggregation level could improve the precision of estimates; however, this is difficult because studies comparing sample designs for aggregated populations have been limited to a few populations and sampling designs, so their results cannot be generalised. To address this gap, we combined simulations of spatial point populations and field counts of three plant species to compare the relative precision of estimates between three sampling methods: simple random sampling (SRS), systematic sampling (SYS) and spatially balanced sampling (SBS). Comparisons were performed on density and aggregation gradients for a range of sample sizes. Our simulations showed that SYS and SBS were always more precise than SRS when individuals were aggregated, reducing sampling variance up to 80% and 60%. The highest precision for estimating population size was always obtained when the average distance between sampling units equalled the diameter of the clusters (i.e. the groups of individuals). The difference in precision was similar for the natural populations, with sampling variance lowered by up to 75% (SYS) and 60% (SBS) compared to SRS. These findings lead us to recommend using SYS or SBS rather than SRS to estimate population size when individuals are spatially aggregated, as these consistently provide more precise estimates. Assessing cluster diameters in the field enables a quick assessment of the potential gain in precision to expect, and thus the best choice of sampling method depending on the trade‐off between precision and field constraints.

17 June 2023 in Biological Conservation
Verified
Journal Article
Closed access
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
OCOcéane Cobelli
Océane Cobelli
ATAdrien Taudière
Adrien Taudière
JAJulien Andrieu
Julien Andrieu
YAYildiz Aumeeruddy-Thomas
Yildiz Aumeeruddy-Thomas
FRFranck Richard
Franck Richard

5 May 2023 in Journal of Ecology
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
ABAurélien Besnard
Aurélien Besnard
ACAnne Charpentier
Anne Charpentier
GPGuillaume Papuga
Guillaume Papuga
The estimation of population size and its variation across space and time largely relies on counts of individuals, generally carried out within spatial units such as quadrats or sites. Missing individuals during counting (i.e. imperfect detection) results in biased estimates of population size and trends. Imperfect detection has been shown to be the rule in animal studies, and most studies now correct for this bias by estimating detection probability. Yet this correction remains exceptional in plant studies, suggesting that most plant ecologists implicitly assume that all individuals are always detected. To assess if this assumption is valid, we conducted a field experiment to estimate individual detection probability in plant counts conducted in 1 × 1 m quadrats. We selected 30 herbaceous plant species along a gradient of conspicuousness at 24 sites along a gradient of habitat closure, and asked groups of observers to count individuals in 10 quadrats using three counting methods requiring progressively increasing times to complete (quick count, unlimited count and cell count). In total, 158 participants took part in the experiment, allowing an analysis of the results of 5024 counts. Over all field sessions, no observer succeeded in detecting all the individuals in the 10 quadrats. The mean detection rate was 0.44 (ranging from 0.11 to 0.82) for the quick count, 0.59 for the unlimited count (range 0.18–0.87) and 0.74 for the cell count (range 0.46–0.94). Detection probability increased with the conspicuousness of the target species and decreased with the density of individuals and habitat closure. The observer's experience in botany had little effect on detection probability, whereas detection was strongly affected by the time observers spent counting. Yet although the more time‐consuming methods increased detection probability, none achieved perfect detection, nor did they reduce the effect on detection probability of the variables we measured. Synthesis. Our results show that detection is imperfect and highly heterogeneous when counting plants. To avoid biased estimates when assessing the size, temporal or spatial trends of plant populations, plant ecologists should use methods that estimate the detection probability of individuals rather than relying on raw counts.

3 March 2026 in Biological Conservation
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
CCChristie Le Coeur
Christie Le Coeur
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
ABAurélien Besnard
Aurélien Besnard
SCSarah Cubaynes
Sarah Cubaynes
CMCélian Monchy
Célian Monchy
OGOlivier Gimenez
Olivier Gimenez

9 July 2024 in Methods in Ecology and Evolution
Verified
Journal Article
Open access
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
FLFabien Laroche
Fabien Laroche
GPGuillaume Papuga
Guillaume Papuga
ABAurélien Besnard
Aurélien Besnard
Population monitoring programmes typically rely on sampling because it is impossible to survey all the sites within the study area. In such a situation, the general recommendation to obtain unbiased estimates of population trends is to select monitoring sites using probability sampling. However, site selection not based on probability sampling, such as selecting sites with the largest abundance of individuals at the beginning of the monitoring programme, is common in practice. Nevertheless, these methods carry the risk of obtaining biased trend estimates. Using simulations, McClure & Rolek (2023) investigated whether three non‐probability sampling site selection methods can yield unbiased trend estimates under some specific conditions. For two of these methods, that is selecting high quality sites and selecting sites known to be occupied, the authors conclude that there is a major risk of obtaining biased trend estimates. For the third method, that is selecting sites with the largest initial abundance, they found conditions in which unbiased estimates can be obtained. They conclude that the general recommendation to use probability sampling should be revised. Here, we show that the authors' results, although perfectly correct, do not invalidate this recommendation. First, we point out that the authors made strong assumptions about the populations' functioning in their simulations, especially that inter‐annual variance in abundance is similar for all sites, which is unlikely in most real populations. We show through simple simulations that even slightly relaxing this assumption invalidates the authors' results. We also point out that for most of the hypotheses made by the authors, it is generally not known at the beginning of a study whether they will be respected. Furthermore, the authors did not provide evidence that selecting sites based on high initial abundance leads to more precise trend estimates than probability sampling methods. Therefore, neither the benefits nor the risks of this method are known. We conclude that until evidence is provided that abundance‐based site selection improves estimate precision and the situations in which it provides unbiased estimates are clearly identified, using probability sampling should remain the rule.

6 September 2022 in bioRxiv
Verified
Preprint
Open access
PDF file
JPJan Perret
Jan Perret
ABAurélien Besnard
Aurélien Besnard
ACAnne Charpentier
Anne Charpentier
GPGuillaume Papuga
Guillaume Papuga
The estimation of population size and its variation across space and time largely relies on counts of individuals, generally carried out within spatial units such as quadrats or sites. Missing individuals during counting (i.e. imperfect detection) results in biased estimates of population size and trends. Imperfect detection has been shown to be the rule in animal studies, and most studies now correct for this bias by estimating detection probability. Yet this correction remains exceptional in plant studies, suggesting that most plant ecologists implicitly assume that all individuals are always detected. To assess if this assumption is valid, we conducted a field experiment to estimate individual detection probability in plant counts conducted in 1×1 m quadrats. We selected 30 herbaceous plant species along a gradient of conspicuousness at 24 sites along a gradient of habitat closure, and asked groups of observers to count individuals in 10 quadrats using three counting methods requiring progressively increasing times to complete (quick count, unlimited count and cell count). In total, 158 participants took part in the experiment, allowing an analysis of the results of 5,024 counts. Over all field sessions, no observer succeeded in detecting all the individuals in the 10 quadrats. The mean detection rate was 0.44 (ranging from 0.11 to 0.82) for the quick count, 0.59 for the unlimited count (range 0.18–0.87) and 0.74 for the cell count (range 0.46-0.94). Detection probability increased with the conspicuousness of the target species and decreased with the density of individuals and habitat closure. The observer’s experience in botany had little effect on detection probability, whereas detection was strongly affected by the time observers spent counting. Yet although the more time-consuming methods increased detection probability, none achieved perfect detection, nor did they reduce the effect on detection probability of the variables we measured. Synthesis . Our results show that detection is imperfect and highly heterogeneous when counting plants. To avoid biased estimates when assessing the size, temporal or spatial trends of plant populations, plant ecologists should use methods that estimate the detection probability of individuals rather than relying on raw counts.